| 100% | TIM | 3 | Former "SNL" regular Meadows |
| 71% | ANA | 3 | Former "SNL" regular Gasteyer |
| 71% | TINA | 4 | Former "SNL" regular Fey |
| 71% | FEY | 3 | Former "SNL" regular Tina |
| 71% | PETE | 4 | Former "SNL" regular Davidson |
| 71% | SLATE | 5 | Former "SNL" regular Jenny |
| 67% | JOEPISCOPO | 10 | Former "SNL" regular known for Sinatra impressions |
| 67% | TIM | 3 | Former "SNL" cast member Meadows |
| 60% | BAYER | 5 | Former "SNL" regular Vanessa who had a recurring role on "Will & Grace" |
| 59% | KRISTENWIIG | 11 | Former "SNL" regular who was Oscar-nominated for 2011's "Bridesmaids": 2 wds. |
| 59% | CHERI | 5 | Former snl star oteri |
| 58% | AIDY | 4 | Former SNL cast member Bryant |
| 54% | TIM | 3 | SNL alum Meadows |
| 54% | ROBERTDOWNEYJR | 14 | Former "SNL" regular who was Oscar-nominated for three movies, including 2023's "Oppenheimer": 3 wds., abbr. |
| 54% | MULANEY | 7 | Former SNL writer and stand-up comedian John |
| 52% | OTERI | 5 | Former 34-Down regular Cheri |
| 50% | ANA | 3 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Gasteyer |
| 50% | MAYA | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular ___ Rudolph |
| 50% | NORM | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Macdonald |
| 50% | OTERI | 5 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Cheri |
| 50% | DANA | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Carvey |
| 50% | OTERI | 5 | Former "S.N.L." regular Cheri |
| 50% | ABBY | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular ___ Elliott |
| 50% | WIIG | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Kristen |
| 50% | DRATCH | 6 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Rachel |
| 50% | MAYA | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Rudolph |
| 50% | NORA | 4 | Former "Saturday Night Live" regular Dunn |
| 47% | ARTIE | 5 | ___ Lange, former "Howard Stern Show" regular |
| 45% | MADTV | 5 | Former "SNL" alternative |
| 44% | NORMMACDONALD | 13 | "Dirty Work" actor and former SNL cast member who plays Fortnite: 2 wds. |