| 100% | REGGIEJACKSON | 13 | Former New York Yankees player who was nicknamed "Mr. October" for his postseason clutch hitting: 2 wds. |
| 52% | CARLOSBELTRAN | 13 | Former NY Mets' legendary outfielder who was nicknamed "Mr. October, Jr." for his performances in postseason games: 2 wds. |
| 48% | GUYLAFLEUR | 10 | A former New York Rangers player who was nicknamed "The Flower" who is considered one of the greatest hockey players in history: 2 wds. |
| 41% | ROBINSONCANO | 12 | New York Mets infielder who is one of three active players with over 2,500 hits (2 wds.) |
| 39% | MATTHARVEY | 10 | New York Mets pitcher who is nicknamed "The Dark Knight": 2 wds. |
| 39% | AARONJUDGE | 10 | New York Yankees outfielder who was the Associated Press Athlete of the Year in 2022: 2 wds. |
| 38% | ALEXRODRIGUEZ | 13 | Former Yankees infielder who was the youngest player to hit 500 career home runs (2 wds.) |
| 36% | FRANKGIFFORD | 12 | Sports commentator and former halfback for "New York Giants" who is known for his work on ABC's "Monday Night Football": 2 wds. |
| 36% | DEREKJETER | 10 | American baseball shortstop nicknamed "Captain Clutch" who spent his entire MLB career with the New York Yankees: 2 wds. |
| 35% | DWIGHTGOODEN | 12 | Pitcher for the 1986 World Series champion New York Mets who was nicknamed "Dr. K": 2 wds. |
| 34% | LEEMAYE | 7 | Former MLB player who was also the lead singer for an LA-based doo-wop group: 2 wds. |
| 34% | EZRACORNELL | 11 | Man for whom a New York Ivy League school is named, who shares his first name with "The Flash" actor Miller: 2 wds. |
| 34% | RUDYGIULIANI | 12 | Former New York City mayor who achieved a "Full Ginsburg" by appearing on five different Sunday morning news shows on October 9, 2016: 2 wds. |
| 33% | THURMANMUNSON | 13 | New York Yankees catching great who was the MLB's AL Rookie of the Year in 1970 (2 wds.) |
| 33% | ROBINSONCANO | 12 | New York Yankees second baseman who was named MVP of the 2013 World Baseball Classic: 2 wds. |
| 33% | AARONJUDGE | 10 | New York Yankees outfielder who also hears cases in court?: 2 wds. |
| 33% | JOEDIMAGGIO | 11 | The New York Yankees retired his number 5: 2 wds. |
| 32% | MELALLEN | 8 | Sportscaster for the Yankees who was known for his line "How about that?!": 2 wds. |
| 32% | MAGICJOHNSON | 12 | A former Basketball player who was part of "The Dream Team," who spent his entire career with the L.A Lakers: 2 wds. |
| 31% | SOSA | 4 | Former baseball player Sammy who was known for his home-run hitting skills in the '90s |
| 31% | HIDEKIMATSUI | 12 | Japanese MLB player who was the 2009 World Series MVP as a Yankee: 2 wds. |
| 31% | LOU | 3 | ___ Gehrig, former baseball player for the New York Yankees who attended Columbia University |
| 31% | RED | 3 | ___ Rolfe, former baseball player for the New York Yankees who attended Dartmouth College |
| 31% | AARONJUDGE | 10 | New York Yankees slugger who wears #99 (2 wds.) |
| 31% | TOM | 3 | ___ Gola, former New York Knicks player who is among those with the most triple-doubles in NBA history |
| 31% | MANTLE | 6 | Mickey —, New York Yankees MLB player who holds the record for most World Series home runs |
| 31% | JALENBRUNSON | 12 | New York Knicks guard named 2025 NBA Clutch Player of the Year: 2 wds. |
| 31% | DAVIDORTIZ | 10 | Former Boston Red Sox hitter who was nicknamed "Big Papi": 2 wds. |
| 31% | ZACKBRITTON | 11 | New York Yankees pitcher who gave up the walk-off home run in the 30-Across game ( 2 wds.) |
| 31% | LOUGEHRIG | 9 | Former New York Yankees baseball player |