| 100% | DAVID | 5 | Former NY Mets' third baseman Wright who was nicknamed "Captain America" after his performance in the 2013 World Baseball Classic |
| 42% | CARLOSBELTRAN | 13 | Former NY Mets' legendary outfielder who was nicknamed "Mr. October, Jr." for his performances in postseason games: 2 wds. |
| 41% | MIKE | 4 | Former NY Mets' legendary catcher Piazza who was nicknamed "The Pizza Man" and was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2016 |
| 37% | TOMSEAVER | 9 | Former NY Mets' legendary pitcher who was nicknamed "The Franchise" and was part of the 1969 World Series team: 2 wds. |
| 32% | ROBINSONCANO | 12 | New York Yankees second baseman who was named MVP of the 2013 World Baseball Classic: 2 wds. |
| 31% | JOSEREYES | 9 | Former NY Mets' infielder who was nicknamed "La Melaza" and was part of the MLB All-Star four times: 2 wds. |
| 31% | CEY | 3 | Former Dodgers third baseman whom Chris Berman nicknamed "Born in the U.S." |
| 29% | SMITH | 5 | NY Mets' first baseman Dominic who is nicknamed "Medium Hurt" |
| 29% | ALEXRODRIGUEZ | 13 | Former Yankees slugger who, in his 2012 children's book, is a young baseballer learning the value of practice: 2 wds. |
| 29% | SOSA | 4 | Former baseball player Sammy who was known for his home-run hitting skills in the '90s |
| 28% | RODRIGUEZ | 9 | Third baseman Alex who was the #1 MLB draft pick (for the Mariners) in 1993 |
| 27% | RICO | 4 | Puerto ___, commonwealth that placed second in the 2013 and 2017 editions of the World Baseball Classic tournament |
| 26% | ONEIL | 5 | Former first baseman Buck who was the first African-American coach in the MLB |
| 26% | DAVID | 5 | ___ Campese, former Australian rugby player who was inducted into the World Rugby Hall of Fame in 2013 |
| 25% | CUBA | 4 | Caribbean island whose team was runner-up in the 2006 World Baseball Classic |
| 24% | DONNCLENDENON | 13 | New York Mets first baseman who was MVP of the 1969 World Series (2 wds.) |
| 24% | DAVIDDUVAL | 10 | American pro golfer who was formerly World No.1, and posted a score of 59 in the 1999 Bob Hope Chrysler Classic: 2 wds. |
| 24% | ORGAN | 5 | Tommy, lead guitarist in The Jacksons' "Unity Tour" of 2012 and 2013, who would seem to be playing the wrong instrument, judging by his name |
| 24% | EVANS | 5 | Chris who is Captain America in Marvel movies |
| 24% | TEBOW | 5 | Former quarterback Tim who plays baseball in the New York Mets' farm system |
| 23% | MARTINSTLOUIS | 13 | Former Lightning captain who is the third-most recent NHL player to win the Art Ross Trophy twice: 3 wds. |
| 23% | ELON | 4 | Musk who is the richest person in the world |
| 23% | CHASEHEADLEY | 12 | Yankees third baseman who, in 2012, won a Gold Glove, a Silver Slugger Award and was also the NL RBI leader, playing for the Padres : 2 wds. |
| 23% | WADE | 4 | Third baseman Boggs inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2005 |
| 23% | HALLE | 5 | Actress Berry who was in the third "John Wick" film |
| 23% | BAER | 4 | Boxer Max who was world heavyweight champion in the thirties |
| 23% | MADISON | 7 | Pitcher Bumgarner who was the World Series MVP in 2014 |
| 23% | RON | 3 | Business honcho Perelman, who was once the richest man in America |
| 23% | MEL | 3 | Allen who was the first host of "This Week in Baseball" |
| 23% | BERRA | 5 | Yogi who was catcher in the only perfect World Series game |