| 100% | SCHILLING | 9 | Former pitcher curt |
| 60% | OREL | 4 | Former pitcher hershiser |
| 56% | OREL | 4 | Former pitcher and ESPN analyst Hershiser |
| 55% | OREL | 4 | Former pitcher and current ESPN analyst Hershiser |
| 55% | OREL | 4 | Former pitcher Hershiser who was nicknamed "Bulldog" |
| 54% | LOES | 4 | Former Brooklyn pitcher |
| 54% | ROE | 3 | Former Brooklyn pitcher |
| 54% | NOLAN | 5 | Former pitcher Ryan who threw seven no-hitters |
| 53% | IRABU | 5 | Former Yankee pitcher Hideki |
| 53% | OREL | 4 | Former Dodgers pitcher Hershiser |
| 53% | OREL | 4 | Former baseball pitcher ___ Hershiser |
| 53% | BRET | 4 | Former baseball pitcher Saberhagen |
| 53% | LOPAT | 5 | Former Yankees pitcher Eddie |
| 53% | OREL | 4 | Former Dodger pitcher Hershiser |
| 53% | OREL | 4 | Former Dodgers' pitcher ___ Hershiser |
| 53% | MADDUX | 6 | Former braves pitcher greg |
| 53% | KAAT | 4 | Former MLB pitcher Jim |
| 53% | RON | 3 | Former Mets pitcher Darling |
| 52% | TUG | 3 | Former pitcher ___ McGraw, country singer Tim McGraw's father |
| 52% | BALL | 4 | "___ Four" (memoir by former pitcher Jim Bouton) |
| 52% | JAE | 3 | Former major-league pitcher ___ Seo |
| 52% | LEA | 3 | Former Expo's pitcher Charles __ |
| 51% | UNIT | 4 | The Big ___ (nickname for former pitcher Randy Johnson) |
| 50% | RON | 3 | Former New York Mets pitcher Darling |
| 50% | MEL | 3 | Former Yankee pitcher and coach Stottlemyre |
| 50% | SEAN | 4 | Former Washington Nationals relief pitcher Doolittle |
| 50% | OREL | 4 | ___ Hershiser, former baseball pitcher |
| 49% | OREL | 4 | Hershiser, American former baseball pitcher |
| 48% | OREL | 4 | Former pitcher Hershiser who's worked on TV as a baseball analyst |
| 48% | OREL | 4 | Former Dodgers pitcher Hershiser who was nicknamed "Bulldog" |