| 100% | DEMENTOR | 8 | Foul creature that guarded Azkaban in the Potterverse |
| 41% | ORC | 3 | Foul creature in the "Lord of the Rings" films |
| 40% | CRAB | 4 | Sea creature that's featured in the zodiac |
| 40% | EARTHWORM | 9 | Wriggly garden creature that lives in the soil |
| 39% | GIANTSQUID | 10 | Creature that attacked the Nautilus in "Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea" |
| 39% | EMU | 3 | Creature that can fill the blank in L___R to make another creature |
| 38% | YETI | 4 | Mythical creature that lives in the Chocolate Mountains, in Candy Crush Saga |
| 38% | DODOS | 5 | Flightless feathered creatures that went extinct in the 17th century |
| 37% | RIOTS | 5 | Events that require bringing in the National Guard, maybe |
| 37% | BAT | 3 | Creature that attacked Meredith in "The Office" |
| 37% | GNU | 3 | Creature that stampeded in "The Lion King" |
| 36% | ZOMBIE | 6 | Mythological undead creature that was featured in the TV series "The Walking Dead" |
| 36% | BIRDS | 5 | Creatures flying in the skies ... or animals that are covered in feathers |
| 36% | LOON | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 36% | WREN | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 36% | OWL | 3 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 36% | JAY | 3 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 36% | HAWK | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 36% | CROW | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 35% | RAT | 3 | Scabbers, in the Potterverse |
| 35% | OWL | 3 | Hermes, in the Potterverse |
| 35% | KNUT | 4 | Coin in the Potterverse |
| 35% | SNAPE | 5 | Professor in the Potterverse |
| 35% | DARKARTS | 8 | Harmful spells, in the Potterverse |
| 35% | KNUT | 4 | Bronze coin in the Potterverse |
| 35% | TROLL | 5 | Tall creature with great strength that the "Harry Potter" trio encountered in a bathroom |
| 34% | DLINE | 5 | Those opposite the center and guards, in N.F.L. lingo |
| 34% | CRABBIEST | 9 | In the foulest mood |
| 34% | LEST | 4 | In the event that |
| 34% | WHILST | 6 | In the time that |