| 100% | REYES | 5 | Four-time M.L.B. All-Star José |
| 77% | MAYS | 4 | Twenty-four-time M.L.B. All-Star Willie |
| 68% | CARLTON | 7 | 11-time M.L.B. All-Star Fisk |
| 68% | STAUB | 5 | Six-time M.L.B. All-Star Rusty |
| 68% | NOLAN | 5 | Many-time M.L.B. All-Star Arenado |
| 68% | BETTS | 5 | Six-time M.L.B. All-Star Mookie |
| 67% | AROD | 4 | 14-time M.L.B. All-Star, to fans |
| 66% | SORIANO | 7 | Alfonso who was a seven-time M.L.B. All-Star |
| 62% | TIM | 3 | M.L.B. All-Star Anderson |
| 60% | REYES | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star Jose |
| 58% | ELLY | 4 | 2024 M.L.B. All-Star ___ De La Cruz |
| 56% | HANKAARON | 9 | Record holder for the most M.L.B. All-Star selections |
| 56% | AROD | 4 | M.L.B. all-time leader in grand slams (25), informally |
| 55% | NOLANRYAN | 9 | M.L.B.’s all-time leader in no-hitters |
| 55% | GASOL | 5 | Four-time N.B.A. All-Star Pau ___ |
| 54% | BOOG | 4 | Four-time '60s-'70s A.L. All-Star __ Powell |
| 53% | REYES | 5 | Four-time major-league All-Star José |
| 48% | IAN | 3 | Four-time All-Star second baseman Kinsler |
| 47% | YAO | 3 | Eight-time N.B.A. All-Star ___ Ming |
| 47% | CANO | 4 | M.L.B. star named for Jackie Robinson |
| 47% | RUTH | 4 | M.L.B. star ejected from 87-Across |
| 47% | TODDHELTON | 10 | Five-time All Star, four-time Silver Slugger, and three-time Golden glove winner |
| 46% | MANNY | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star ___ Trillo |
| 46% | ONEILL | 6 | Four-time Yankee All-Star Paul |
| 46% | KYRIE | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star __ Irving |
| 46% | RONDO | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star Rajon ___ |
| 46% | KAWHI | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star Leonard |
| 46% | UPTON | 5 | Four-time MLB all-star Justin |
| 46% | ICHIRO | 6 | All-time single-season hits leader in M.L.B. history (262) |
| 46% | SALBANDO | 8 | Four-time All-Star third baseman of the 1960s-'70s |