| 100% | ONEILL | 6 | Four-time Yankee All-Star Paul |
| 59% | DEREK | 5 | 14-time Yankees All-Star shortstop Jeter |
| 58% | MANNY | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star ___ Trillo |
| 58% | REYES | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star Jose |
| 58% | KYRIE | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star __ Irving |
| 58% | RONDO | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star Rajon ___ |
| 58% | KAWHI | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star Leonard |
| 58% | UPTON | 5 | Four-time MLB all-star Justin |
| 57% | BRYCE | 5 | Four-time MLB All-Star slugger ___ Harper |
| 57% | IAN | 3 | Four-time MLB All-Star infielder Kinsler |
| 56% | RAJON | 5 | Four-time NBA All-Star point guard Rondo |
| 55% | IAN | 3 | Four-time All-Star second baseman Kinsler |
| 55% | REYES | 5 | Four-time major-league All-Star José |
| 54% | GASOL | 5 | Four-time N.B.A. All-Star Pau ___ |
| 54% | REYES | 5 | Four-time M.L.B. All-Star José |
| 54% | TODDHELTON | 10 | Five-time All Star, four-time Silver Slugger, and three-time Golden glove winner |
| 53% | BOOG | 4 | Four-time '60s-'70s A.L. All-Star __ Powell |
| 53% | RANG | 4 | The bell ___ four times before it was all over. |
| 53% | LUIS | 4 | Yankees All-Star pitcher Severino |
| 52% | SALBANDO | 8 | Four-time All-Star third baseman of the 1960s-'70s |
| 52% | CANO | 4 | Robinson ___, many-time Yankees and Mariners All-Star |
| 50% | TINO | 4 | Nineties Yankee All-Star Martinez |
| 50% | TINO | 4 | Former Yankees All-Star Martinez |
| 50% | KEANU | 5 | Reeves who starred in all four "Matrix" films |
| 48% | BOGART | 6 | American Film Institute's "greatest male star of all time" |
| 47% | ANAPEST | 7 | It occurs four times in "'Twas the night before Christmas, when all through the house" |
| 47% | RODLAVER | 8 | Tennis star who won all four Grand Slam titles in 1969 |
| 47% | MARIA | 5 | Tennis star Sharapova who has won all four major tennis tournaments |
| 47% | SCHITTSCREEK | 12 | Comedy series whose four stars all won acting Emmys in 2020 |
| 46% | ALLIE | 5 | 40's-50's Yankees All-Star pitcher Reynolds |