| 100% | BREAM | 5 | Freshwater fish (rhymes with "cream") |
| 93% | BREAM | 5 | Deep-bodied freshwater fish that rhymes with cream |
| 84% | CARP | 4 | Freshwater fish (rhymes with "harp") |
| 81% | GAR | 3 | A freshwater fish with a long jaw; rhymes with far |
| 71% | CARP | 4 | Freshwater game fish (rhymes with "tarp") |
| 68% | BREAM | 5 | Freshwater fish with silvery scales |
| 67% | GAR | 3 | Freshwater fish with bill-like jaws |
| 67% | SALMON | 6 | Freshwater fish with orange-pink meat |
| 67% | GAR | 3 | Freshwater fish with a long snout |
| 62% | RUDD | 4 | European freshwater fish with a dark greenish body |
| 62% | PIRANHA | 7 | Freshwater tropical fish with sharp teeth |
| 62% | PIRANHA | 7 | Freshwater carnivorous fish with sharp teeth |
| 61% | DACE | 4 | European freshwater fish with a slender bluish-green body |
| 61% | RUDD | 4 | European freshwater fish with a compressed dark-greenish body |
| 61% | DACE | 4 | European freshwater fish with a slender, bluish-green body |
| 61% | RUDD | 4 | European freshwater fish with a compressed dark greenish body |
| 61% | COD | 3 | Fish that rhymes with "rod" |
| 61% | EELS | 4 | Fish Nash rhymed with ''meals'' |
| 60% | EEL | 3 | Fish, that rhymes with heel |
| 59% | TENCH | 5 | European freshwater fish with olive-green skin and orange-red eyes |
| 58% | PIRANHA | 7 | Small freshwater fish of tropical America with strong jaws and sharp teeth |
| 57% | LOX | 3 | Fish often paired with cream cheese |
| 55% | BASS | 4 | Freshwater or seawater fish with a striped variety, which has dichromatic vision |
| 55% | EEL | 3 | Slippery fish that rhymes with "meal" |
| 55% | SMELT | 5 | Small fish that rhymes with "dealt" |
| 54% | GRAYLING | 8 | Freshwater food fish of the salmon family with a long high dorsal fin |
| 52% | WALLEYEDPIKE | 12 | North American freshwater fish [with an inside track] |
| 52% | GAR | 3 | Narrow bony fish (rhymes with "mar") |
| 52% | CARP | 4 | Freshwater fish |