| 100% | NEWBIE | 6 | Frosh, in September |
| 67% | SEE | 3 | "___ You in September" |
| 65% | SNR | 3 | Frosh in three years: Abbr. |
| 63% | FALL | 4 | Season starting in September |
| 63% | SEE | 3 | Happenings "___ You in September" |
| 63% | ELM | 3 | Something shedding in September |
| 63% | PEAR | 4 | Fruit harvested in September |
| 61% | EDSEL | 5 | Car introduced in September 1957 |
| 61% | SEE | 3 | The Happenings "___ You in September" |
| 61% | NEW | 3 | Released in September 2019, say |
| 61% | FALL | 4 | Season that begins in September |
| 61% | LABOR | 5 | ___ Day (first Monday in September) |
| 61% | LABORDAY | 8 | It comes early in September |
| 61% | DAY | 3 | One of 30 in September |
| 60% | SOPH | 4 | Frosh, in a couple of semesters |
| 60% | THEMEEE | 7 | Annual gala usually held in September |
| 60% | LABOR | 5 | ___ Day (the first Monday in September) |
| 60% | IAN | 3 | Hurricane that struck Florida in September |
| 58% | WILL | 4 | "___ & Grace" (sitcom returning to NBC in September) |
| 58% | SEX | 3 | "___ Education" (Netflix show that ended in September) |
| 58% | IDES | 4 | September 13 in old Rome |
| 56% | AUTUMN | 6 | In 2021, it begins September 22nd |
| 55% | VIRGOS | 6 | People born in September, under sign of a maiden |
| 55% | SERENA | 6 | Tennis player Williams who had a daughter in September |
| 55% | OCASEK | 6 | Cars lead singer Ric who died in September 2019 |
| 55% | BRAD | 4 | Altman, George Takei's husband, married in September 2008 |
| 55% | SEGA | 4 | Company that released the Genesis Mini console in September |
| 55% | ADNANSYED | 9 | "Serial" subject whose conviction was vacated in September 2022 |
| 55% | COOLIO | 6 | “Gangsta’s Paradise” rapper who died in September, 2022 |
| 55% | DVDS | 4 | Items that Netflix will stop mailing in September: Abbr. |