| 100% | CORNCOB | 7 | Frosty's pipe was made out of this |
| 63% | SEAWEED | 7 | Nori sheets are made out of this |
| 63% | PLASTIC | 7 | Disposable utensils are made out of this material |
| 56% | CORNCOB | 7 | Core of an ear which Frosty's pipe is made of |
| 54% | EYES | 4 | Frosty the Snowman's facial features that were made out of coal |
| 52% | CHILI | 5 | Eating a few of these will make steam come out of your ears |
| 51% | METAL | 5 | What staples are made out of |
| 50% | ONE | 3 | Being this, out of a million, makes you really special |
| 50% | VINYL | 5 | What record albums are made out of |
| 50% | ISLES | 5 | What some chains are made out of |
| 49% | COAL | 4 | What Frosty's eyes are made of |
| 49% | TIRES | 5 | What the Michelin Man is made out of |
| 49% | PLASTIC | 7 | What many water bottles are made out of |
| 49% | CARDBOARD | 9 | Stiff paper material that boxes are made out of |
| 49% | PORCELAIN | 9 | White ceramic material that china is made out of |
| 49% | TIN | 3 | Dorothy's friend was made of this metal |
| 47% | NECKING | 7 | Making out ... or a hint to this puzzle's four hidden articles of clothing |
| 46% | COB | 3 | What Frosty the Snowman's pipe was made from |
| 45% | ISLANDS | 7 | Hawaii is made up of these land masses |
| 45% | TINPLATE | 8 | Beer cans are made of this |
| 45% | BEESWAX | 7 | Some candles are made of this |
| 45% | KERATIN | 7 | Fingernails are made of this substance |
| 45% | ANACHRONISM | 11 | This is always out of time |
| 45% | NECESSITY | 9 | At times virtues are made of this |
| 45% | BEESWAX | 7 | Honeycombs are made of this natural balm |
| 45% | DEAN | 4 | ___ Martin, "Memories Are Made of This" singer |
| 45% | ACRES | 5 | A lot can be made of these |
| 45% | TOWN | 4 | Hotel guests are often out of this |
| 44% | NAM | 3 | Place where "We Gotta Get Out of This Place" was popular, briefly |
| 44% | SILICONE | 8 | Heat-resistant bakeware is made of this rubber |