| 100% | ELENORE | 7 | Gee, I think you're swell |
| 85% | ELENORE | 7 | "Gee, I think you're swell" girl of a 1960s song |
| 57% | NOT | 3 | "You're ___ who I thought you were" |
| 55% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something!" |
| 55% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something" |
| 54% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something here!" |
| 54% | POINT | 5 | "I think you're missing the ___" |
| 54% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something there" |
| 54% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something here" |
| 54% | WRONGNUMBER | 11 | "Sorry, I think you misdialed" |
| 53% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something" ("Good idea") |
| 53% | AGREED | 6 | "I think you're right about that" |
| 52% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something here!": 2 wds. |
| 52% | ONTO | 4 | "I think you're ___ something there" (2 wds.) |
| 52% | TIM | 3 | Robinson of I Think You Should Leave |
| 51% | LEAVE | 5 | I Think You Should ___ (Netflix sketch series starring Tim Robinson) |
| 50% | ELSE | 4 | "I think you have me confused with someone ___" |
| 49% | KNOW | 4 | "I ___ what you're thinking ..." |
| 49% | SOWHAT | 6 | You think I care? |
| 48% | OWE | 3 | "I think I ___ you an explanation" |
| 48% | ETTU | 4 | "I thought I could trust you!" |
| 47% | ESP | 3 | You thinking what I'm thinking? |
| 47% | AWMAN | 5 | "Gee, you're killin' me!" |
| 47% | LET | 3 | "___ me know what you think" |
| 46% | ARE | 3 | "___ you thinking what I'm thinking?" |
| 46% | DOIT | 4 | "I think you should!" |
| 46% | IMNOFOOL | 8 | “Don’t think you can put one over on me!” |
| 45% | WHOME | 5 | "Wait, you think I did that?" |
| 45% | TMI | 3 | "I think you overshared," briefly |
| 45% | ASK | 3 | "I thought you'd never ___!" |