| 100% | FAUST | 5 | Goethe character who makes a pact with the devil |
| 68% | FAUST | 5 | Classic literary character who makes a deal with the devil |
| 63% | FAUST | 5 | He made a pact with the Devil |
| 53% | UNHOLY | 6 | Like a pact with the Devil |
| 53% | FAUSTIAN | 8 | Like a pact with the devil |
| 49% | FAUST | 5 | He made a deal with the devil |
| 45% | LIN | 3 | Houston Rockets point guard Jeremy who made a big splash with the Knicks |
| 45% | PACT | 4 | Someone striking a deal with the Devil makes one |
| 44% | TAROT | 5 | It can help you make a deal with The Devil? |
| 44% | DOROTHY | 7 | Character who sings with the Scarecrow in "If I Only Had a Brain" |
| 43% | KIM | 3 | ___ Kardashian, celebrity who made a fashion statement with her Pearl Dress at the 2023 Met Gala |
| 43% | NED | 3 | Groundhog Day character who, according to a fan theory, is actually the devil |
| 42% | HALO | 4 | Xbox game series with the A.I. character who inspired Microsoft's voice-assistant Cortana |
| 42% | HALO | 4 | Xbox game series with the A.I. character who inspired Microsoft's voice assistant Cortana |
| 42% | MRKRABS | 7 | Animated character who, in one episode, fills out a crossword with only the word money |
| 40% | TALK | 4 | Make a deal with the feds, say |
| 40% | PROSPERO | 8 | Character who says "We are such stuff
as dreams are made on, and our little life is rounded with a sleep" |
| 39% | PEG | 3 | ___ Bundy, character from the series "Married... with Children" who qualifies to be a couch potato |
| 39% | HOMERSIMPSON | 12 | TV character who says "It's 1 a.m. Better go home and spend some quality time with the kids" |
| 39% | PAM | 3 | "The Office" character who had a romance with Jim |
| 38% | TOMGLAVINE | 10 | A pitcher who made his name with the Atlanta Braves and New York Mets is a 10-time All-Star: 2 wds |
| 38% | CHER | 4 | Singer who made a comeback in 1999 with "Believe" |
| 38% | ALCOCK | 6 | John W —, English aviator who, with A W Brown, made the first non-stop flight across the Atlantic |
| 38% | PAW | 3 | "___ Patrol," Canadian animated TV series with animals as the main characters that was made into a feature movie |
| 38% | DEVIL | 5 | Being who makes a deal with Faust |
| 38% | CHAR | 4 | Actor who played a character with the same first name on "Two and a Half Men" |
| 38% | BLINK | 5 | Make a quick gesture with the eye |
| 38% | APACT | 5 | Make ___ with the devil |
| 38% | ANTHONY | 7 | Celebrity chef ___ Bourdain, who made a cameo in "The Simpsons" along with Gordon Ramsay |
| 37% | GHOSTFACE | 9 | Antagonist with a mask in the "Scream" movies who made everyone scream |