| 100% | AMULET | 6 | Good luck with that! |
| 60% | CHARM | 5 | Good luck ___ (something that is believed to bring good luck) |
| 57% | ADDER | 5 | Snake that's good with numbers? |
| 57% | BRIE | 4 | Cheese that's good with fruit |
| 57% | BREAKALEG | 9 | “Good luck with your performance!” |
| 56% | EYECONTACT | 10 | Something that good speakers make with audiences |
| 56% | YUM | 3 | "___! That tastes good!" (rhymes with "gum") |
| 55% | SHADES | 6 | With 40-Across, distinctions that are neither good nor bad... |
| 55% | CRACKERS | 8 | Wheat-based disks that are good with cheese |
| 55% | FOR | 3 | Preposition that goes with a jolly good fellow |
| 54% | BIBLICAL | 8 | Something that has to do with the Good Book |
| 54% | SCONE | 5 | Bready baked good that might be served with tea |
| 53% | AMULET | 6 | Charm that brings good luck |
| 53% | OKAY | 4 | "I'm good with that" |
| 53% | SUITSME | 7 | "I'm good with that" |
| 53% | KIWI | 4 | Fuzzy fruit with a golden variety that is SO GOOD |
| 52% | EYE | 3 | Organ that's all the better to see you with |
| 52% | FORTUNA | 7 | Typeface that shares its name with the Roman goddess of luck |
| 51% | FOOT | 4 | Rabbit's ___, amulet believed to bring good luck that was once gifted to President Theodore Roosevelt |
| 51% | BAD | 3 | With 35-Across, Taylor Swift hit that won the 2016 Best Music Video Grammy |
| 51% | THEGREATEST | 11 | With 42-Across, 1952 circus film that won the Best Picture Oscar: 2 wds. |
| 50% | ZEST | 4 | An enthusiastic person has ___ for life (a word that rhymes with best) |
| 50% | ECON | 4 | A subject or class in college that deals with goods and services |
| 50% | ANITA | 5 | Baker with the #3 hit "Giving You the Best That I Got" |
| 50% | FARGO | 5 | North Dakota city that shares its name with a Best Picture nominee |
| 50% | JADE | 4 | Gem associated with good luck in Chinese culture |
| 50% | EIGHT | 5 | Number associated with good luck, in Chinese culture |
| 49% | IMNOT | 5 | With 49-Across, song that won 14-Across his Best Country Song Grammy: 2 wds. |
| 49% | FORTUNE | 7 | Good luck |
| 49% | ANITA | 5 | Singer Baker with the 1988 hit "Giving You the Best That I Got" |