| 100% | GUMBY | 5 | Green clay character with a horse named Pokey |
| 84% | GUMBY | 5 | Green claymation character with a horse named Pokey |
| 58% | CASPER | 6 | Cartoon character with a horse named Nightmare |
| 55% | GUMBY | 5 | Claymation character with a pony named Pokey |
| 47% | GUMBY | 5 | Claymation character with a horse |
| 47% | ZORRO | 5 | Swordsman with a horse named Tornado |
| 46% | LARUE | 5 | Movie cowboy with a horse named Rush |
| 46% | CASPER | 6 | Cartoon ghost with a horse named Nightmare |
| 46% | ZORRO | 5 | *Fictional swordfighter with a horse named Tornado |
| 45% | GUMBY | 5 | Green claymation character who rode a pony named Pokey |
| 45% | ROYROGERS | 9 | Old time movie cowboy with a horse named Trigger |
| 44% | LUIGI | 5 | Nintendo character with a green cap |
| 43% | KYLE | 4 | "South Park" character with a green hat |
| 43% | DORA | 4 | Animated character with a monkey sidekick named Boots |
| 43% | DORA | 4 | Cartoon character with a monkey friend named Boots |
| 43% | ELOISE | 6 | Kidlit character with a pet turtle named Skipperdee |
| 43% | AMERICA | 7 | A Horse With No Name band |
| 42% | BERT | 4 | "Sesame Street" character with a pet pigeon named Bernice |
| 42% | ELMO | 4 | Kids' TV character with a pet fish named Dorothy |
| 42% | BAMBI | 5 | Disney character with a friend named Thumper |
| 42% | DOUG | 4 | Nicktoon character with a dog named Porkchop |
| 42% | DENNISNACE | 10 | Comics character with a dog named Ruff |
| 42% | ELOISE | 6 | Title character with a pug named Weenie |
| 42% | ANNA | 4 | "Frozen" character with a palindromic name |
| 42% | BABAR | 5 | Kid-lit character with a green suit and gold crown |
| 42% | PHAETON | 7 | Light four-wheeled horse-drawn carriage usually with two seats whose name derives from a character in Greek mythology |
| 42% | SNOW | 4 | ___ White, Disney character with a weather condition to her name |
| 42% | PHOEBE | 6 | "Friends" character with a twin named Ursula |
| 41% | MRBILL | 6 | Clay character on S.N.L. with a girlfriend named Miss Sally |
| 41% | RAJ | 3 | "The Big Bang Theory" character with a Yorkshire terrier named Cinnamon |