| 100% | RAM | 3 | Gridder with horns on his helmet |
| 45% | RHINO | 5 | Animal with horns on its snout |
| 41% | RAMS | 4 | They have horns on their helmets |
| 41% | COLTS | 5 | Squad with horseshoes on their helmets |
| 41% | RAMS | 4 | Gridders whose helmets depict horns |
| 37% | LIAR | 4 | One with his pants on fire, idiomatically |
| 37% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet with his own "world" on "Sesame Street" |
| 37% | GRAPH | 5 | ___ paper (sheet with a grid printed on it) |
| 37% | PADRE | 5 | Ballplayer with "SD" on his cap |
| 36% | HOPSCOTCH | 9 | Kids' outdoor game with grid chalked on the floor |
| 36% | OZZIENELSON | 11 | He played himself as the dad on his show with wife Harriet: 2 wds. |
| 36% | MARIO | 5 | Nintendo's Italian plumber whose games are centered on his relationship with Princess Peach |
| 35% | AMERICA | 7 | Song with the lyrics "God shed his grace on thee" |
| 34% | KEN | 3 | He reunited with his fictional ex on Valentine's Day in 2011 |
| 33% | WEMADETOOMANY | 13 | With 15-Down, his take on why the Yankees lost the 1960 World Series |
| 33% | ESTHER | 6 | Book that says "Mordecai rent his clothes, and put on sackcloth with ashes" |
| 33% | GREASYNEALE | 11 | Football Hall-of-Famer with a nickname befitting his elusiveness on the field |
| 33% | ATLAS | 5 | Someone with a lot on his shoulders |
| 33% | ODIN | 4 | God with two ravens on his shoulders |
| 33% | ATLAS | 5 | Man with the world on his shoulders |
| 33% | BIGEATER | 8 | Person with a lot on his plate? |
| 33% | ELROY | 5 | Toon with an antenna on his cap |
| 33% | SPONGEBOB | 9 | With 39-Across, Bikini Bottom fry cook who made his TV debut on May 1, 1999 |
| 32% | NOELGALLAGHER | 13 | Guitarist who played with his brother Liam on the Oasis hit "Wonderwall": 2 wds. |
| 32% | MATRIX | 6 | Grid with numbers |
| 32% | CROSSWORDS | 10 | Grids with clues |
| 32% | ONTHEROAD | 9 | Jack Kerouac's most loved novel based on his travels with his friends across the United States: 3 wds. |
| 32% | NAT | 3 | Baseballer with a "W" on his cap |
| 32% | RHINO | 5 | Large animal with a horn on its nose |
| 31% | KLAXON | 6 | Horn on antique cars |