| 100% | PIMENTO | 7 | Grilled-cheese option |
| 82% | CHIVE | 5 | Cream cheese option |
| 80% | HALLOUMI | 8 | Grilled cheese |
| 79% | REUBENS | 7 | Grilled cheese sandwiches |
| 77% | TOMATOSOUP | 10 | Grilled cheese go-with |
| 75% | TOMATOSOUP | 10 | Grilled cheese sandwich go-with |
| 72% | QANDA | 5 | Grilling option |
| 69% | SWEETPICKLE | 11 | Freebie with a grilled cheese sandwich |
| 69% | TOMATOSOUP | 10 | Common grilled cheese sandwich go-with |
| 69% | EBAY | 4 | "Virgin Mary in Grilled Cheese" site |
| 69% | FOODCOLORING | 12 | Ingredient in a rainbow grilled cheese |
| 69% | TOMATOSOUP | 10 | Dish often paired with grilled cheese |
| 68% | BRAT | 4 | Grill option, for short |
| 68% | MELTED | 6 | Like cheddar in a grilled cheese sandwich |
| 68% | APRIL | 5 | National Grilled Cheese Month, in the US |
| 68% | QUESADILLA | 10 | Mexican version of a grilled cheese sandwich |
| 67% | TOASTIE | 7 | Grilled sandwich, often containing cheese |
| 66% | APRIL | 5 | Month when National Grilled Cheese Sandwich Day falls |
| 66% | OFFMENU | 7 | Like grilled cheese at McDonald's, e.g. |
| 66% | PANINIPRESS | 11 | Exercise done by making a grilled cheese sandwich? |
| 64% | GREASY | 6 | Like the bread in a buttery grilled cheese sandwich |
| 63% | SECRETMENU | 10 | Where a grilled cheese can be found at McDonald's |
| 62% | HALLOUMI | 8 | Cypriot "squeaky" cheese, grilled or barbecued |
| 62% | PROVOLONE | 9 | Italian cheese sometimes smoked or grilled |
| 61% | VEGGIE | 6 | With 20-Across, meatless grilling option |
| 60% | REUBENS | 7 | Grilled sandwiches with corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese |
| 59% | TOMATOSOUP | 10 | Grilled-cheese accompaniment |
| 59% | MELT | 4 | Grilled-cheese relative |
| 56% | BAGEL | 5 | Breakfast option often topped with cream cheese and lox |
| 52% | CUBAN | 5 | Grilled ham-and-cheese sandwich |