| 100% | SIGNALS | 7 | Hand gestures used to influence a baseball pitcher |
| 51% | ROSIN | 5 | What a baseball pitcher uses to improve their grip on the ball |
| 44% | HIGHSIGN | 8 | Gesture used to signal a warning: 2 wds. |
| 42% | ERA | 3 | Stat that a baseball pitcher wants to be low: Abbr. |
| 42% | ERA | 3 | Stat that a baseball pitcher wants to keep low: Abbr. |
| 41% | BAT | 3 | What's used to hit a baseball |
| 41% | VEE | 3 | Hand gesture that means "Two please," to a maître d' |
| 40% | SIGN | 4 | Gesture a catcher flashes to a pitcher |
| 39% | TAR | 3 | Pine ___ (resin used to improve grip on a baseball bat) |
| 39% | TARPS | 5 | Coverings used to keep baseball infields dry during a storm |
| 39% | DRIBBLING | 9 | Using one hand to repeatedly bounce a ball |
| 39% | DECANTER | 8 | A pitcher used to hold wine |
| 39% | ERA | 3 | Baseball statistic a pitcher wants to keep low: Abbr. |
| 38% | OARS | 4 | Tools used to propel a canoe or boat forward by hand |
| 36% | POPSOCKET | 9 | Hand-held device used to hold a handheld device |
| 36% | THUMB | 5 | Hand digit that is used to hitch a ride |
| 35% | ARM | 3 | Most important body part for a baseball pitcher |
| 35% | PAW | 3 | What a dog uses to shake your hand |
| 35% | LSD | 3 | Pitcher Dock Ellis claimed to have used this before throwing a no-hitter in 1970 |
| 35% | ARM | 3 | A baseball pitcher needs a good one |
| 35% | ATBAT | 5 | Opportunity against a baseball pitcher |
| 35% | EARNEDRUN | 9 | Stat for a baseball pitcher |
| 34% | JACKARMSTRONG | 13 | Fitting name for a baseball pitcher |
| 34% | ERA | 3 | Statistic for a baseball pitcher: Abbr. |
| 34% | ERA | 3 | Stat for a baseball pitcher: Abbr. |
| 34% | PEG | 3 | Good name for a baseball pitcher? |
| 34% | ATBAT | 5 | Facing a baseball pitcher: 2 wds. |
| 34% | BALK | 4 | Illegal move from a baseball pitcher |
| 34% | BALK | 4 | False motion by a baseball pitcher |
| 34% | PAW | 3 | What a boxer may use to shake your hand |