| 100% | FAUST | 5 | He made a pact with the Devil |
| 82% | FAUST | 5 | He made a deal with the devil |
| 79% | FAUST | 5 | Goethe character who makes a pact with the devil |
| 67% | UNHOLY | 6 | Like a pact with the Devil |
| 67% | FAUSTIAN | 8 | Like a pact with the devil |
| 56% | PACT | 4 | Someone striking a deal with the Devil makes one |
| 56% | TAROT | 5 | It can help you make a deal with The Devil? |
| 56% | FAUST | 5 | Classic literary character who makes a deal with the devil |
| 51% | TALK | 4 | Make a deal with the feds, say |
| 49% | BLACKSMITH | 10 | He makes a bolt for the door |
| 49% | APACT | 5 | Make ___ with the devil |
| 48% | BLINK | 5 | Make a quick gesture with the eye |
| 47% | BECKONING | 9 | Making a curling motion with the forefinger, maybe |
| 47% | TRIP | 4 | Make a mistake on "Dancing With the Stars," say |
| 46% | EASE | 4 | "The ___ with which he pulled it off made him look like a pro." |
| 45% | PACT | 4 | Something Faust reportedly made with the devil |
| 43% | LOOTS | 5 | Makes off with the goods, in a way |
| 43% | LIN | 3 | Houston Rockets point guard Jeremy who made a big splash with the Knicks |
| 43% | MULAN | 5 | Disney film with the song "I'll Make a Man Out of You" |
| 43% | MULAN | 5 | 1998 movie with the song "I'll Make a Man Out of You" |
| 43% | DIGGING | 7 | The act of making holes in the ground with a spade |
| 42% | FEEDING | 7 | When a zookeeper makes the rounds with a bucket |
| 42% | SLAP | 4 | "They let him off with a ___ on the wrist" |
| 42% | NOWHEREMAN | 10 | 1965 song with the lyric "Isn't he a bit like you and me?" |
| 41% | DUTCHTREATIES | 13 | Pacts with the Netherlands? |
| 41% | PIERCE | 6 | To make a hole in the skin with a sharp object |
| 41% | FITTINGS | 8 | Goes with fixtures, part of the make up of a house |
| 41% | FATSWALLER | 10 | He had a hit with "The Joint Is Jumpin'" |
| 41% | NDA | 3 | Billie Eilish song with the lyric "Didn't change my number, made him shut his mouth" |
| 41% | KIM | 3 | ___ Kardashian, celebrity who made a fashion statement with her Pearl Dress at the 2023 Met Gala |