| 100% | SAGE | 4 | Herb in a Simon & Garfunkel song |
| 84% | THYME | 5 | Parsley, sage, rosemary, and ___ (herbs in a Simon & Garfunkel song) |
| 79% | THYME | 5 | Last herb in a Simon & Garfunkel title |
| 78% | THYME | 5 | Last herb in a Simon & Garfunkel album title |
| 61% | DARKNESS | 8 | "My old friend," in a Simon & Garfunkel classic |
| 60% | ATTHEZOO | 8 | Where "giraffes are insincere," in a Simon & Garfunkel hit |
| 59% | APR | 3 | Mo. at the start of a Simon & Garfunkel song |
| 57% | ZOO | 3 | Where "it's all happening," according to a Simon & Garfunkel song |
| 56% | JULIO | 5 | Schoolyard pal in a Paul Simon song |
| 56% | JULIO | 5 | Schoolyard character in a Paul Simon song |
| 55% | VAIN | 4 | Adjective describing Warren Beatty in a Carly Simon song |
| 50% | MINT | 4 | Herb in a mojito |
| 49% | DILL | 4 | Herb in a cucumber salad |
| 49% | BABY | 4 | "___ Driver," 2017 action film starring Lily James, that took its title from a Simon & Garfunkel song |
| 49% | DILL | 4 | Herb in a creamy potato salad |
| 49% | CATNIP | 6 | Herb in a toy mouse, perhaps |
| 48% | SHE | 3 | "April Come ___ Will," a song by Simon & Garfunkel |
| 48% | MINT | 4 | Leafy herb in a mojito |
| 48% | SAGE | 4 | "Wise" herb in a salad? |
| 47% | AAS | 3 | Batteries in a Simon Says toy |
| 47% | BASIL | 5 | Fresh herb in a Margherita pizza |
| 47% | BASIL | 5 | Green herb in a caprese salad |
| 47% | MINT | 4 | Refreshing herb in a cocktail, perhaps |
| 47% | METERMAID | 9 | Municipal employee in a Beatles song |
| 47% | JUDE | 4 | Title fellow in a Beatles song |
| 47% | RITA | 4 | Title woman in a Beatles song |
| 47% | RUDOLPH | 7 | Team leader in a seasonal song |
| 47% | EADIE | 5 | Title lady in a 1933 song |
| 47% | ATRAIN | 6 | Title transport in a 1941 song |
| 47% | CALIFORNIAGIRLS | 15 | Demographic lauded in a 1965 song |