| 100% | HORN | 4 | Honking ___, noisy accessory that adds a comedic touch to your "Clown" Halloween costume |
| 51% | TOP | 3 | ___ hat, formal headwear that adds a touch of sophistication to your "Vampire" Halloween costume |
| 43% | WIG | 3 | Rainbow ___, vibrant hairpiece with multiple hues that adds to your "Clown" Halloween costume |
| 42% | LAMP | 4 | Indoor decor item that adds a glowing touch to your desk or bedside table |
| 42% | PALM | 4 | Houseplant with large leaves that adds a tropical touch to your space |
| 41% | BIG | 3 | ___ shoes, oversized footwear that adds to your whimsical "Clown" Halloween costume |
| 40% | EYE | 3 | ___ patch, face accessory that would be a great addition to your "Pirate" Halloween costume |
| 40% | LACE | 4 | Delicate fabric that adds elegance to your "Fairy" Halloween costume |
| 35% | PARROT | 6 | Green feathered companion that would be a great addition to your "Pirate" Halloween costume |
| 35% | BELT | 4 | Utility ___, accessory that holds your tools and is a component of your "Superhero" Halloween costume |
| 34% | BELL | 4 | Jingly addition to your "Cat" Halloween costume that rings when you move |
| 33% | MASK | 4 | Face-covering accessory that hides your true identity and is a component of your "Superhero" Halloween costume |
| 33% | FANGS | 5 | Pointed dental accessories that define your "Vampire" Halloween costume |
| 30% | PROVISO | 7 | Clause that adds a condition to a contract |
| 30% | HAT | 3 | "Hold On To Your ___," Rolling Stones song that might pop into your head while reaching for a brimmed accessory from the closet |
| 29% | WITCH | 5 | Halloween costume that often includes a broom |
| 29% | PIN | 3 | Accessory that might be attached to a lapel |
| 29% | GHOST | 5 | Halloween costume that can be made from a sheet |
| 29% | SATAN | 5 | Halloween costume that may involve horns and a tail |
| 29% | TOGA | 4 | Halloween costume that can be made from a bedsheet |
| 29% | LIPSTICK | 8 | Cosmetic that adds color to a mouth |
| 28% | ICED | 4 | Added the finishing touches to a cake |
| 28% | METS | 4 | Team that added a purple "Grimace seat" to Citi Field in 2024 |
| 28% | SATAN | 5 | Halloween costume that may involve a red cape and tail |
| 28% | MARIO | 5 | Halloween costume that often includes suspenders and a fake mustache |
| 28% | KAZOO | 5 | Toy instrument that adds buzzing to your voice |
| 28% | GARNISH | 7 | Ornamental item that adds decoration to a plate |
| 28% | GLOSS | 5 | Makeup that adds a bright finish to lips |
| 28% | SUIT | 4 | Super ___, outfit you wear to fight crime that is a component of your "Superhero" Halloween costume |
| 28% | OVEN | 4 | Kitchen's "bake-a-licious" appliance that adds a golden twist to your dishes! |