| 100% | ILLGOSEE | 8 | Horror film line that usually gets its speaker in trouble |
| 37% | DEAD | 4 | "The Evil ___," 1981 horror film starring Bruce Campbell that got a nostalgic nod in "Stranger Things" |
| 37% | THING | 5 | "The ___," 1982 sci-fi horror film starring Kurt Russell that got a nostalgic nod in "Stranger Things" |
| 36% | ELM | 3 | "A Nightmare on ___ Street," 1984 horror film starring Robert Englund that got a nostalgic nod in "Stranger Things" |
| 36% | GEICO | 5 | Company whose spoofed horror film ad has the line, "Why can't we just get in the running car?" |
| 34% | SAW | 3 | Horror film that starts in a lavatory |
| 34% | SAW | 3 | Horror film that starts in a filthy lavatory |
| 33% | SAW | 3 | Horror film franchise with its seventh sequel in 2017 |
| 32% | MOM | 3 | Shout that might get a sibling in trouble |
| 32% | SASS | 4 | Talk that might get a teen in trouble |
| 31% | EVIL | 4 | "The ___ Within," 2017 horror film that was in production for 15 years |
| 31% | LEVEE | 5 | Bank that may get in trouble? |
| 30% | TOM | 3 | "Peeping ___," 1960 horror film that was referenced in Wes Craven's "Scream 4" |
| 30% | SASS | 4 | Verbal response that could get a child in trouble |
| 30% | ADLIB | 5 | Remark that might get one in trouble |
| 30% | SASS | 4 | Talk that might get one in trouble |
| 30% | ADLIB | 5 | Remark that might get you in trouble |
| 30% | LIBEL | 5 | Writing that can get you in trouble |
| 30% | CREEK | 5 | "Willow ___," 2013 horror film directed by Bobcat Goldthwait that is set in the woods |
| 30% | PORNO | 5 | Film that might have "XXX" in its title |
| 30% | BAIL | 4 | You get in trouble if you skip it |
| 30% | BLAIR | 5 | "The ___ Witch Project," psychological horror film where a documentary crew gets lost in the woods |
| 30% | SECONDS | 7 | 1966 horror film that became known for how it influenced the Beach Boys' Brian Wilson |
| 30% | ACTIVITY | 8 | "Paranormal ___," 2007 supernatural horror film that is centered around camera footages in a haunted house |
| 29% | TYCO | 4 | Mattel subsidiary that got its start in model trains |
| 29% | LARGO | 5 | Key that got its first post office in 1870 |
| 29% | TITANIC | 7 | Film that was rereleased in 3-D nearly fifteen years after its initial première |
| 29% | CANNES | 6 | Film festival that awarded its top prize to Anatomy of a Fall in 2023 |
| 29% | COPY | 4 | "Yes, I got that!" as you'd hear it in radio communication |
| 29% | LLBEAN | 6 | Co. that got its own ZIP code in 1976 |