| 100% | EVENLY | 6 | How to spread peanut butter in a sandwich |
| 47% | FLUTTERNUTTER | 13 | Word for a peanut-butter-and-marshmallow-creme sandwich that was added to Merriam-Webster in 2021 |
| 45% | KNIFE | 5 | Utensil that can be used to spread peanut butter |
| 43% | ONRYE | 5 | How ham may be served in a sandwich |
| 42% | HOP | 3 | How to move in a sack race |
| 42% | PATIENTLY | 9 | How to wait in a clinic, say |
| 41% | EDGEWAYS | 8 | How to put a coin in a coin slot |
| 41% | SIR | 3 | How to address a male superior officer in the army |
| 41% | LOG | 3 | Celery, in a peanut butter and raisins snack |
| 40% | ROW | 3 | How to go "gently down the stream," in a nursery rhyme |
| 39% | ANTSONALOG | 10 | Snack that uses peanut butter to hold raisins in place |
| 38% | PINECONE | 8 | Item covered with peanut butter to make a bird feeder: 2 wds. |
| 38% | CRUSTLESS | 9 | How a sandwich might be served to a picky child |
| 38% | UNDERAFALSENAME | 15 | How a rock star might check in to a hotel |
| 37% | MAKEYOURWAY | 11 | With 26-Down, how to succeed in business, and a hint to this puzzle |
| 37% | ALPHABETICALLY | 14 | How to link the 12 letters in this puzzle with a single line to make a picture |
| 37% | STEP | 4 | Instruction in a how-to manual |
| 37% | STEPS | 5 | List in a how-to manual |
| 36% | STICK | 5 | Butter in a box |
| 36% | REESES | 6 | Candy brand with a "Peanut Butter & Banana Creme" variety released as a tribute to Elvis in 2007 |
| 36% | STEPS | 5 | Numbered things in a how-to manual |
| 36% | STEP | 4 | Single instruction in a how-to guide |
| 36% | STEPS | 5 | Numbered instructions in a how-to manual |
| 36% | GHEE | 4 | Butter in a biryani recipe |
| 35% | CREAMY | 6 | Alternative to "chunky," in peanut butter |
| 35% | HAM | 3 | Cured meat paired with cheese in a sandwich |
| 35% | BACON | 5 | B, in a sandwich |
| 35% | HAM | 3 | Meat in a sandwich |
| 35% | TRIMTHETREE | 11 | Decorate for Christmas, in a way, and how to make sense of the answer to each starred clue? |
| 35% | PAPI | 4 | “Hola ___: How to Come Out in a Walmart Parking Lot and Other Life Lessons” (John Paul Brammer memoir) |