| 100% | STIRRING | 8 | How witches mix up ingredients in cauldrons |
| 38% | TOEOFFROG | 9 | Ingredient in a witches' brew |
| 38% | CAKEBATTER | 10 | Mix up in the kitchen? |
| 37% | OFNEWT | 6 | Ingredient in a witch's potion |
| 37% | TABASCO | 7 | Ingredient in some Bloody Mary mixes |
| 37% | STIR | 4 | Mix soup ingredients in a pot, say |
| 37% | TOEOFFROG | 9 | Ingredient in the witches' brew in "Macbeth" |
| 36% | RYE | 3 | ___ chips (dark ingredients in Chex Mix) |
| 36% | RYE | 3 | ___ chips (crispy ingredient in Chex Mix) |
| 36% | MARINARA | 8 | Sauce made from ingredients mixed up in 16-, 24-, 37- and 49-Across |
| 35% | AUDIO | 5 | A duo I mixed up in hearing |
| 35% | STIR | 4 | Mix ingredients in a bowl |
| 35% | BREW | 4 | Witches' ___ (concoction in a cauldron) |
| 35% | BREW | 4 | Witches’ ___ (concoction in a cauldron) |
| 35% | STIRS | 5 | Mixes ingredients in a pot |
| 35% | ADD | 3 | Put one more ingredient in the mix, say |
| 35% | POTIONS | 7 | Witches brew these liquids in cauldrons |
| 35% | STIR | 4 | Mix ingredients together in a bowl |
| 34% | NEWT | 4 | "Eye of ___ and toe of frog ... " (cauldron ingredients for the Witches in "Macbeth") |
| 34% | ASEA | 4 | In a mixed up state |
| 33% | NOTBYALONGSHOT | 14 | How to score in basketball from close up? |
| 32% | BREW | 4 | Bubbling concoction in a witch's cauldron |
| 31% | OVEN | 4 | Where the witch in "Hansel and Gretel" ends up |
| 31% | OVEN | 4 | Where the witch in "Hansel and Gretel" ended up |
| 31% | APPLE | 5 | Chopped-up ingredient in a Waldorf salad |
| 31% | BLEND | 5 | Mix together, as smoothie ingredients... or a word that ends in "end" |
| 30% | CAFFEINE | 8 | Pick-me-up ingredient in tea and coffee |
| 30% | GARBLED | 7 | In mixed-up condition |
| 30% | CHEMICALPOOLS | 13 | Wagers about how many ingredients are in a bottle of shampoo? |
| 29% | STIRBUNNY | 9 | *Terse instruction to a rabbit to mix things up in the kitchen? |