| 100% | MIRAGE | 6 | I'm back to anger apparition |
| 55% | MINDFUL | 7 | Aware I'm back to fund new student |
| 48% | UMM | 3 | "Come back to me?" |
| 46% | IREMEMBER | 9 | “It just came back to me” |
| 46% | ITS | 3 | "___ all coming back to me now" |
| 46% | HAUNT | 5 | "This is gonna come back to ___ me" |
| 45% | AHYES | 5 | "It's all coming back to me now" |
| 45% | BASIA | 5 | “Until You Come Back to Me” singer (1990) |
| 44% | LET | 3 | "___ me get back to you" |
| 44% | ARETHA | 6 | “Until You Come Back to Me” singer Franklin (1973) |
| 44% | ITS | 3 | Celine Dion's "___ All Coming Back to Me Now" |
| 44% | SORTYOURSELFOUT | 15 | "Come back to me when things are less hectic" |
| 43% | DION | 4 | "It's All Coming Back to Me Now" singer Celine |
| 43% | ILL | 3 | "___ get back to you" ("You'll be hearing from me") |
| 43% | ILLSEE | 6 | "Let me get back to you" (2 wds.) |
| 43% | LET | 3 | "___ me get back to you on that" |
| 43% | IMAY | 4 | “Let me get back to you” |
| 42% | ONBENDEDKNEE | 12 | Boyz II Men 1994 hit with the line "I'm begging you, begging you come back to me": 3 wds. |
| 42% | REDEEM | 6 | Wild deer force me to get back |
| 42% | ITSMEAGAIN | 10 | "I'm back!" … or a hint to 17-, 24-, 38- and 51- Across |
| 41% | CELINE | 6 | With 11-Down, "It's All Coming Back to Me Now" singer |
| 41% | HEAR | 4 | "Are you able to ___ me at the back?" |
| 40% | EGAL | 4 | "Ça m'est ___" ("It doesn't matter to me") |
| 40% | MISSME | 6 | "Glad I'm back?" |
| 39% | EMBARGO | 7 | Take me back to pub and leave ban |
| 39% | ALMA | 4 | "Carry Me Back to Old Virginny" singer Gluck |
| 39% | DEMONS | 6 | Professors get me back to spirits |
| 39% | MISSME | 6 | “Are you glad I’m back?” |
| 39% | PEI | 3 | I.M. who went to MIT |
| 39% | GYPSY | 5 | Fleetwood Mac hit that begins, “So I’m back to the velvet underground” |