| 100% | CONE | 4 | I'm the shape of a party hat or a Christmas tree |
| 58% | CYLINDER | 8 | I'm the shape of a battery or a can |
| 58% | CUBE | 4 | I'm the shape of a die or sugar, perhaps |
| 58% | SPHERE | 6 | I'm the shape of a globe or an orange |
| 47% | CONE | 4 | Shape of a party hat |
| 44% | CONE | 4 | Shape of a party hat, which may also be an ice cream holder |
| 42% | MINIFIG | 7 | Lego piece in the shape of a person or animal |
| 41% | PEAR | 4 | Body shape or a fruit mentioned in "The Twelve Days of Christmas" |
| 40% | ESCROW | 6 | A bond or deed kept in the custody of a third party |
| 40% | PALM | 4 | Kind of a tree, or a part of the hand |
| 40% | LETO | 4 | Jared ___, I'm the frontman of 30 Seconds to Mars and a film star born the day after Christmas. Who am I? |
| 40% | TOPIARY | 7 | The art of trimming trees or hedges into shapes |
| 39% | CRESCENT | 8 | Banana shape, or a phase of the moon |
| 39% | CANDYCANE | 9 | Christmas tree decoration ... or a hint to what the circled letters form |
| 38% | BONNET | 6 | Hood of a car or the hat worn at Easter |
| 38% | PEAR | 4 | A partridge's tree in a Christmas song, or a distinctively shaped fruit |
| 38% | PINE | 4 | Christmas tree type with a scent that may remind you of the holidays |
| 38% | CONIC | 5 | Shaped like a party hat |
| 38% | CONE | 4 | Shape of a birthday hat |
| 38% | PINATA | 6 | The hit of a party? |
| 38% | ARC | 3 | The shape of a rainbow |
| 37% | UPROOT | 6 | Pull out of the ground, as a plant or tree |
| 37% | CASHEW | 6 | Kidney-shaped nut grown from the fruit of a tree |
| 37% | RED | 3 | The shade of a cardinal perched on a cherry tree |
| 37% | DIAMOND | 7 | The shape of a baseball field |
| 37% | SEMI | 4 | The shape of a protractor, __-circle |
| 37% | LEG | 3 | Shape of a fragile lamp in "A Christmas Story" |
| 37% | ITMEANSALOTTOME | 15 | "I'm deeply indebted" ... or a hint to the ends of 17-, 25-, 51- and 64-Across |
| 37% | BAR | 3 | Shape of a Three Musketeers or Snickers |
| 37% | OVAL | 4 | Shape of a cricket ground or racetrack |