| 71% | DIDNTWORKOUT | 12 | "So then I dated a fun couch potato, but he ..." |
| 48% | TYPE | 4 | "He's really not my ___" ("Don't set me up on a date with him") |
| 47% | WOULDNEVERFLY | 13 | "Then I had a fling with a Pittsburgh Penguin, but I knew he ..." |
| 45% | LETMEDOWN | 9 | "I dated my rock climbing instructor for a while, but he just ..." |
| 43% | ARTICLE | 7 | A but not I |
| 42% | MESS | 4 | "Clutchin' their pearls, sighing, 'What a ___'" ("But Daddy I Love Him" lyric) |
| 42% | ELEMENT | 7 | He or I, but not him |
| 42% | ELEMENT | 7 | He or I, but not she |
| 42% | KEY | 3 | A or E, but not I |
| 41% | ELEM | 4 | He or I, but not you: Abbr. |
| 40% | CHEMICALSYMBOLS | 15 | He and I, but not she and you |
| 40% | RENO | 4 | "But I shot a man in ___ just to watch him die" (Johnny Cash line) |
| 40% | RENO | 4 | "But I shot a man in ___ just to watch him die" (Johnny Cash lyric) |
| 40% | RENO | 4 | "But I shot a man in ___ just to watch him die" ("Folsom Prison Blues") |
| 40% | PAINE | 5 | He wrote that government "is but a necessary evil" |
| 40% | KEYS | 4 | A and E, but not I, O or U |
| 40% | ALERS | 5 | A and O, but not E, I or U |
| 40% | NOTE | 4 | A or E, but not I, O or U |
| 39% | OWES | 4 | "He ___ me one" ("I did him a favor") |
| 39% | OHNOEWHEISMYEX | 14 | *"Yuck! I've dated him before. Swipe left!" |
| 38% | RENO | 4 | “But I shot a man in ___, just to watch him die” (Johnny Cash lyric) |
| 38% | CAMETONOTHING | 13 | "Then my friend set me up with a recluse, but he ..." |
| 38% | ELTON | 5 | He sang a 2022 duet of "Hold Me Closer" with Britney |
| 38% | OWES | 4 | "He ___ me big time" ("I did him a huge favor") |
| 38% | OWES | 4 | "He ___ me big time!" ("I did him a huge favor") |
| 38% | AINT | 4 | "I may not be the brightest, but I ____ a liar!" |
| 38% | DONTKNOWTHERITEPEOPLE | 21 | "I always wanted to be a wedding officiant, but I ... " |
| 38% | NEVERGOTTHECHANTS | 17 | "I always wanted to be a Gregorian monk, but I ... " |
| 38% | IMPORTANT | 9 | "I'm late! I'm late! For a very __ date!" |
| 38% | DIDTHETRICK | 11 | "Finally, I started seeing a charming magician, and he ..." |