| 100% | AGLOW | 5 | In "The Christmas Song" Nat King Cole sang about the "tiny tots with their eyes all ___" |
| 55% | AGLOW | 5 | "Tiny tots with their eyes all ___" ("The Christmas Song" lyric) |
| 41% | AGLOW | 5 | ''Tiny tots with their eyes all __'' |
| 39% | KINGCOLE | 8 | Nat __ sang The Christmas Song in 1961 |
| 38% | MONA | 4 | "___ Lisa," Nat King Cole's song about the eponymous painting |
| 37% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Nat King Cole sang about roasting these |
| 37% | UNFORGETTABLE | 13 | Song of the Year Grammy winner (1992) sung by Nat King Cole and Natalie Cole |
| 37% | AGLOW | 5 | Like the eyes of tiny tots, in a classic Christmas carol |
| 36% | NAT | 3 | ___ King Cole who sang "The Christmas Song" |
| 33% | DECK | 4 | "___ the Halls," song by Nat King Cole |
| 32% | NAT | 3 | "The Christmas Song" singer ___ King Cole |
| 31% | CIRCUS | 6 | Britney Spears song with the lyric "All the eyes on me in the center of the ring" |
| 31% | DEFYING | 7 | With 48-Across, song sung by Elphaba in the musical "Wicked" |
| 31% | JOYTOTHEWORLD | 13 | Christmas song with the lyric "And heaven and nature sing" (4 wds.) |
| 31% | NAT | 3 | Cole who sang "The Christmas Song" |
| 30% | NEW | 3 | With 65- and 66-Across, when to sing the song in the circled squares |
| 30% | TOTS | 4 | "Tiny ___ with their eyes all aglow will find it hard to sleep tonight" |
| 29% | ROUTE | 5 | (3/3) "(Get Your Kicks on) ___ 66," song by Nat King Cole about a cross-country road trip |
| 29% | SILVERBELLS | 11 | Classic Christmas song with the lyric "City sidewalks, busy sidewalks, / Dressed in holiday style" |
| 29% | THEREISNOTHING | 14 | With 119-Across, “South Pacific” song ... or a declaration about the nine women featured in this puzzle? |
| 29% | UNFORGETTABLE | 13 | Nat King Cole song |
| 29% | BECAUSEOFRAIN | 13 | Nat King Cole song |
| 29% | YMCA | 4 | Where "you can hang out with all the boys," in song |
| 29% | DECK | 4 | "___ the Halls," song by Nat King Cole that is one of the shortest songs to enter the Billboard charts |
| 29% | LSD | 3 | Drug that the song "Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds" is rumored to be about: Abbr. |
| 29% | CROONS | 6 | Sings like Nat King Cole |
| 29% | CROON | 5 | Sing like Nat King Cole |
| 28% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Nat King Cole sang that they roast on open fires |
| 28% | NESTLED | 7 | "The children were ___ all snug in their beds" ("'Twas the Night Before Christmas" line) |