| 100% | PIEDPIPER | 9 | In legend, he lured rats from Hamelin |
| 46% | SIGMUND | 7 | In German legend, he pulled a sword from a tree |
| 41% | FAUST | 5 | In legend he sold his soul to the devil |
| 41% | NERO | 4 | In legend, he fiddled in a fire |
| 40% | SAINTPATRICK | 12 | He drove the serpents from Ireland, in legend |
| 39% | LORELEI | 7 | Siren in German legend said to lure boatmen to destruction from her rock at the edge of the Rhine |
| 37% | SPY | 3 | He "came in from the cold" |
| 37% | SPY | 3 | He came in from the cold |
| 36% | LIOTTA | 6 | He played Sinatra in "The Rat Pack" |
| 36% | ABU | 3 | He steals the lamp from Jafar in "Aladdin" |
| 36% | WESER | 5 | River in which the Pied Piper drowned Hamelin’s rats, according to legend |
| 35% | ALEXANDER | 9 | He cut the Gordian Knot in an ancient legend |
| 35% | GOLEMS | 6 | Creatures in Jewish legend created from mud |
| 34% | HERCULES | 8 | He went from zero to hero in a Disney movie song |
| 34% | THOR | 4 | He called Hulk a "friend from work," in a Marvel movie |
| 34% | TIRESIAS | 8 | Blind prophet from legend found in The Waste Land |
| 34% | TROTSKY | 7 | He was expelled from the Soviet Union in 1929 |
| 33% | APU | 3 | Hank Azaria stepped away from voicing him in January |
| 32% | ELVIS | 5 | He performed 636 consecutive sold-out shows in Vegas from 1969 to '76 |
| 32% | GELERT | 6 | Dog who saved a baby from a wolf in Welsh legend |
| 32% | EXCALIBUR | 9 | Sword that King Arthur pulled from a stone, in English legend |
| 31% | STROMBOLI | 9 | The Blue Fairy helped Pinocchio escape from him, in the Disney film |
| 31% | LORELEI | 7 | Siren in German legend said to lure boatmen from her rock at the edge of the Rhine |
| 31% | CHARLIEHUNNAM | 13 | He played King Arthur in 2017's "King Arthur: Legend of the Sword": 2 wds. |
| 31% | MARIANORIVERA | 13 | He pitched in 1,115 games for the Yankees from 1995 to 2013: 2 wds. |
| 31% | ROBINWILLIAMS | 13 | He played Mork from Ork in a "Happy Days" spin-off: 2 wds. |
| 30% | LAURENCEOLIVIER | 15 | He played a Nazi in "Marathon Man" and a Nazi hunter in "The Boys From Brazil" [Connecticut] |
| 29% | FLORIDA | 7 | Rapper and singer whose name comes from the state he was born in: 2 wds. |
| 29% | TRISTAN | 7 | Brad Pitt played him in Legends of the Fall |
| 29% | MIKESTANTON | 11 | He pitched in 1,178 games for eight teams, including the Braves, from 1989 to 2007: 2 wds. |