| 100% | ATOLL | 5 | Island with a lagoon |
| 70% | ATOLL | 5 | Island in a lagoon |
| 69% | ATOLL | 5 | Island with a reef |
| 68% | ELLIS | 5 | Island with a Great Hall |
| 68% | BALI | 4 | Island with a Hindu majority |
| 68% | OAHU | 4 | Island with a state capital |
| 68% | OAHU | 4 | Island with a royal palace |
| 68% | BERMUDA | 7 | Island with a famous triangle |
| 68% | OAHU | 4 | Island with a trisyllabic name |
| 68% | STATEN | 6 | Island with a famous ferry |
| 68% | BERMUDA | 7 | Island with a namesake Triangle |
| 67% | IONA | 4 | Island with a 13th-century cathedral |
| 66% | SKYE | 4 | Island with a terrier named for it |
| 66% | OAHU | 4 | Island with a U.S. state capital |
| 66% | BALI | 4 | Island with a lot of yoga retreats |
| 65% | ALCATRAZ | 8 | Island with a view of the Golden Gate |
| 65% | HONSHU | 6 | Island with a population of about 100 million |
| 65% | BERMUDA | 7 | Island with a triangle whose abbreviation is BM |
| 65% | LILLIPUT | 8 | Fictional island with a small population |
| 65% | BALI | 4 | Indonesian island with a famous "swing" |
| 65% | JAVA | 4 | Indonesian island with a namesake sea |
| 64% | CATALINA | 8 | Resort island with a noted seal colony |
| 64% | OAHU | 4 | U.S. island with a royal palace |
| 64% | BALI | 4 | Indonesian island with a mostly Hindu population |
| 64% | BORABORA | 8 | French Polynesian island with a repeating name |
| 64% | IBIZA | 5 | Spanish island with a famous club scene |
| 63% | GUAM | 4 | Pacific island with a U.S. military base |
| 62% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island with a population of around one million |
| 61% | ICELAND | 7 | Island with the Blue Lagoon and Gullfoss Falls |
| 61% | OAHU | 4 | Hawaiian island with a population of around 1,000,000 |