| 100% | TRICK | 5 | It might fool Penn & Teller on "Penn & Teller: Fool Us" |
| 57% | PENN | 4 | "___ & Teller: Fool Us" (show on the CW) |
| 57% | SALT | 4 | It may replace sugar, on April Fool's Day |
| 51% | APRIL | 5 | You may be fooled on its first day |
| 51% | THECGOYA | 8 | "Penn & Teller: Fool Us" airer |
| 49% | DECOY | 5 | It may fool you |
| 47% | CUE | 3 | It may help you go on |
| 46% | LAPTOP | 6 | It might have an apple on it |
| 46% | SHEEN | 5 | It might be a reflection on you |
| 46% | RAIN | 4 | It might get the drop on you |
| 46% | TNT | 3 | It may be brought up on charges |
| 46% | SONG | 4 | It may be broken into on Broadway |
| 46% | SUNDAE | 6 | It may have a cherry on top |
| 46% | TREAD | 5 | It may leave its mark on the road |
| 46% | CANDY | 5 | It may go on sale on November 1 |
| 46% | SLEEVE | 6 | It might be rolled up on a farm |
| 46% | MENU | 4 | It might have sides listed on the side |
| 46% | ASP | 3 | It might cause a death on the Nile |
| 46% | INK | 3 | It might be a blot on your record |
| 46% | PEN | 3 | It might get ink stains on your fingers |
| 46% | CEREAL | 6 | It might have a game on the back |
| 46% | BRIM | 4 | It may be turned down on the street |
| 46% | PROD | 4 | It may give a shock on a ranch |
| 46% | RADAR | 5 | It may give a reflection on a highway |
| 46% | JOWL | 4 | It may get a nip on "Nip/Tuck" |
| 46% | ABSENCE | 7 | It may be put down on a roll |
| 46% | SLEEVE | 6 | It may be rolled up on a farm |
| 46% | SHELL | 5 | It may be found lying on the beach |
| 46% | APP | 3 | It may have an icon on your smartphone |
| 46% | OATER | 5 | It may be partly set on a stage |