| 100% | PRIZE | 5 | Item that was removed from boxes of Cracker Jack in 2016 |
| 37% | EGG | 3 | Food item that will float in a bowl of water if it's old |
| 36% | REDS | 4 | M&M's that were removed from 1976 to 1987 out of a health concern for a coloring dye |
| 36% | KEYS | 4 | Typically lost items that are "found" in the starts of 16-, 24-, 45- and 57-Across |
| 35% | HAT | 3 | Item of clothing that a man is supposed to remove when indoors |
| 34% | COINS | 5 | Items that can circulate or be tossed ... as illustrated in this puzzle's six sets of circles |
| 34% | EAT | 3 | Enjoy a box of Cracker Jack, say |
| 34% | ICEPICK | 7 | Item used in the murder of Johnny Boz that detective Nick Curran was investigating |
| 33% | STREETTRAMS | 11 | Railed vehicles that are kind of out of place but they stop you from getting suckered in |
| 33% | CLOAK | 5 | ___ of invisibility, magical object in "Harry Potter" that prevents the wearer from being seen |
| 33% | DICE | 4 | Items that are rolled in many games |
| 33% | CATTOYS | 7 | Gifts that might be ignored in favor of the cardboard boxes they came in |
| 32% | NKOTB | 5 | Boy band that was big in the '80s (when most of the items in the theme answers came out), briefly |
| 32% | ARK | 3 | Item that was "lost" in a 1981 Harrison Ford movie |
| 32% | ALCOA | 5 | It was removed from the Dow in 2013 |
| 32% | ORANGES | 7 | Grove items that are rich in Vitamin C |
| 32% | EGGS | 4 | Food items that are often sold in dozens |
| 32% | CDS | 3 | Music items that are sold in cases: Abbr. |
| 31% | HAT | 3 | Something that is removed as a mark of respect |
| 31% | CHIA | 4 | ___ Pet (novelty item that was popular in the 1980s) |
| 31% | OLD | 3 | Word for vintage items that is hidden in "gold" |
| 31% | CORVETTE | 8 | One of the most iconic American sports cars from Chevrolet, that has been in production for seven generations |
| 31% | CHIP | 4 | Item that might be dipped in salsa |
| 31% | PEN | 3 | Item that might be twirled in class |
| 31% | MALEV | 5 | Airline that was the flag carrier of Hungary from 1946 until it declared insolvency in 2012 |
| 31% | BORNTORUN | 9 | Bruce Springsteen's autobiography that was named after an iconic album and song of his, and was released in September 2016: 3 wds. |
| 31% | CDS | 3 | Items that were sold at records stores starting in the 1980s: Abbr. |
| 31% | OMELETTE | 8 | Denver ___, eggy breakfast item that was originated in Denver, Colorado |
| 31% | TIE | 3 | Item that may be in a Pratt knot |
| 31% | ORES | 4 | Items that can be smelted in Stardew Valley |