| 100% | DICE | 4 | Items that are rolled in many games |
| 54% | DICE | 4 | Pair of items rolled in many board games |
| 53% | DIE | 3 | Cube rolled in many games |
| 52% | DOUGH | 5 | Cookie batter that is rolled in a bakery |
| 50% | DICE | 4 | Cubes rolled in many board games |
| 50% | DIE | 3 | Cube rolled in many board games |
| 50% | OREO | 4 | Snack item that has been made in more than 85 flavors |
| 49% | DICE | 4 | Objects rolled in many a board game |
| 49% | ARK | 3 | Item that was "lost" in a 1981 Harrison Ford movie |
| 49% | EGGS | 4 | Food items that are often sold in dozens |
| 48% | PRIZE | 5 | Item that was removed from boxes of Cracker Jack in 2016 |
| 48% | CHIP | 4 | Item that might be dipped in salsa |
| 48% | PEN | 3 | Item that might be twirled in class |
| 48% | CDS | 3 | Items that were sold at records stores starting in the 1980s: Abbr. |
| 47% | ORANGES | 7 | Grove items that are rich in Vitamin C |
| 47% | CDS | 3 | Music items that are sold in cases: Abbr. |
| 47% | ORES | 4 | Items that can be smelted in Stardew Valley |
| 47% | TIE | 3 | Item that may be in a Pratt knot |
| 47% | ROULETTE | 8 | Game that was rigged in "Casablanca" |
| 47% | NKOTB | 5 | Boy band that was big in the '80s (when most of the items in the theme answers came out), briefly |
| 47% | DVDS | 4 | Items that Netflix will stop mailing in September: Abbr. |
| 47% | ERASER | 6 | Item that might be kept in a pencil case |
| 47% | TINS | 4 | Metal items that muffins are baked in |
| 46% | SOCKS | 5 | Clothing items that are, in another sense, a synonym for "belts" |
| 46% | OREO | 4 | Dessert item that was clued as "Mountain: Comb. form" in old crosswords |
| 46% | ETAS | 4 | Items that the Amtrak website will tell you, in brief |
| 46% | RAZOR | 5 | Item that might be in a Dollar Shave Club package |
| 46% | AMP | 3 | Item that "goes to 11," in "This Is Spinal Tap" |
| 46% | TACOS | 5 | Food items that may be sold in stands |
| 46% | CTRL | 4 | Computer key that is used in many shortcuts |