| 100% | RODRIGUEZ | 9 | Ivan ___, former baseball catcher nicknamed "Pudge" who has 13 Gold Gloves |
| 55% | MADDUX | 6 | Greg ___, former baseball pitcher nicknamed "Mad Dog" who has a record-setting 18 Gold Gloves |
| 45% | KAAT | 4 | Jim ___, former baseball pitcher who has 16 Gold Gloves and was a 3-time All-Star |
| 44% | MAYS | 4 | Willie ___, former baseball center fielder nicknamed "the Say Hey Kid" who has 12 Gold Gloves and was a 24-time All-Star |
| 43% | IVAN | 4 | Former baseball catcher Rodríguez who's called "Pudge" |
| 41% | OZZIE | 5 | Baseballer Smith who won 13 consecutive Gold Gloves |
| 36% | ROBERTO | 7 | ___ Alomar, former second baseman who has 10 Gold Gloves and was a 12-time All-Star |
| 36% | MIKE | 4 | Former NY Mets' legendary catcher Piazza who was nicknamed "The Pizza Man" and was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2016 |
| 35% | ALEX | 4 | ___ Rodriguez, former baseball shortstop who was nicknamed "A-Rod" |
| 35% | ABBY | 4 | Wambach who has two Olympic gold medals in 13-Down |
| 34% | IAN | 3 | Second baseman Kinsler who has two Gold Glove Awards |
| 34% | AROD | 4 | Former baseball player who has been a guest shark on "Shark Tank," familiarly: Hyph. |
| 32% | AROD | 4 | Nickname of a former Yankee who appears on ESPN's "Sunday Night Baseball": Hyph. |
| 31% | OZZIESMITH | 10 | St. Louis Cardinals shortstop who won 13 Gold Gloves: 2 wds. |
| 31% | IVAN | 4 | Retired baseball catcher Rodriguez whose nickname is "Pudge" |
| 31% | IVAN | 4 | Former MLB catcher ___ Rodriguez, nicknamed "Pudge" |
| 31% | NED | 3 | Former baseball catcher and manager Yost |
| 31% | OZZIE | 5 | Shortstop Smith who won 13 consecutive Gold Glove Awards |
| 31% | IVAN | 4 | Former catcher Rodríguez nicknamed "Pudge" |
| 30% | LARISA | 6 | ___ Latynina, gymnast who represented former Soviet Union and has won 18 Olympic gold medals |
| 30% | MITTS | 5 | Baseball catcher's gloves |
| 30% | MITT | 4 | Baseball catcher's glove |
| 30% | CARL | 4 | Former athlete ___ Lewis who has won nine Olympic gold medals |
| 29% | PETE | 4 | ___ Gray, former baseball outfielder who was inducted into the Baseball Reliquary's Shrine of the Eternals despite having lost his arm |
| 29% | SOSA | 4 | Former baseball star nicknamed "Slammin' Sammy" |
| 29% | TORRE | 5 | Joe ___, American former baseball player who has achieved over 2,000 hits as a player and 2,000 wins as a manager |
| 29% | DAVID | 5 | Former NY Mets' third baseman Wright who was nicknamed "Captain America" after his performance in the 2013 World Baseball Classic |
| 28% | CEY | 3 | Ron ___, former baseballer nicknamed "the Penguin" |
| 28% | RYNE | 4 | Baseball Hall of Famer Sandberg who earned nine Gold Gloves with the Cubs |
| 28% | MITT | 4 | Catcher's baseball glove |