| 100% | DEVIL | 5 | Jersey ___, modern legendary creature that is said to inhabit the Pine Barrens forest |
| 41% | YETI | 4 | Legendary creature said to inhabit the Himalayas |
| 41% | PINE | 4 | ___ Barrens, forest in New Jersey said to be haunted by the Jersey Devil |
| 38% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Modern legendary creature that is a blood-sucking monster |
| 38% | LOCHNESS | 8 | Modern legendary creature that is a sea monster: 2 wds. |
| 36% | YETI | 4 | Creature said to inhabit the Himalayas |
| 35% | HELLFIRE | 8 | Flames that are said to be the punishment of sinners |
| 34% | WATER | 5 | ___ Bearer, shape of a human that is said to be represented by the constellation Aquarius |
| 33% | RATS | 4 | Creatures that the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 33% | JAW | 3 | Body part that is said to "hit the floor" when someone is surprised |
| 32% | BELL | 4 | ___ Witch Cave, karst cave in Tennessee that is said to be haunted and inspired the film, "An American Haunting" |
| 32% | IMSUCHAJERK | 11 | "So sorry, that was totally the wrong thing to say!" |
| 32% | SEATURTLE | 9 | Creature that returns to the beach where it was born for laying eggs |
| 32% | LEMP | 4 | ___ Mansion, historical house in Missouri that is said to be haunted and has appeared on the TV series, "Ghost Hunters" |
| 31% | OHIO | 4 | State that's said to be "high in the middle" |
| 31% | POT | 3 | Container that's said to be at the end of a rainbow |
| 30% | AREA | 4 | ___ 51, said to be a government facility that is the subject of UFO conspiracy theories |
| 30% | ABUNDANCE | 9 | Mentality that is said to attract wealth |
| 30% | ELEPHANTS | 9 | Animals that are said to never forget |
| 30% | BUNNY | 5 | Easter ___, modern legendary creature that appears on Easter |
| 30% | ELEPHANT | 8 | Large mammal that is said to never forget |
| 30% | ASP | 3 | Snake that is said to have killed Cleopatra |
| 30% | CURSES | 6 | Hexes that are said to generate bad luck |
| 29% | ELIXIR | 6 | "The ___ of Life," a drink that is said to cure all ills |
| 29% | FAIRY | 5 | Tooth ___, modern legendary creature that exchanges teeth for money |
| 29% | ASP | 3 | Egyptian viper that is said to have killed Cleopatra |
| 29% | PINE{APPLE}CAKE | 15 | Taiwanese dessert that is said to bring good luck |
| 29% | MEERKATS | 8 | Animals that are said to be immune to snake venom |
| 29% | ARK | 3 | Boat that is said to have landed on Mount Ararat |
| 29% | SILVER | 6 | Type of bullet that is said to kill a werewolf |