| 100% | TORRE | 5 | Joe who managed the Mets, Braves, Cardinals, Yankees and Dodgers |
| 55% | DAVEY | 5 | Johnson who managed the Mets, Reds, Orioles, Dodgers and Nationals |
| 49% | TORRE | 5 | Joe who managed the Yankees for 12 seasons |
| 48% | TORRE | 5 | Joe who managed the Yankees to four World Series championships |
| 45% | ART | 3 | Howe who managed the Astros, A's, and Mets |
| 44% | LARUSSA | 7 | Tony who managed the A's and Cardinals to World Series titles |
| 38% | GIL | 3 | Hodges who managed the Mets to a World Series title |
| 38% | GIL | 3 | Hodges who managed the Miracle Mets |
| 38% | HODGES | 6 | Gil who managed the “Miracle Mets” |
| 37% | DAVEY | 5 | Johnson who managed the 1986 championship Mets |
| 37% | ELIA | 4 | Lee who managed the Cubs and Phillies |
| 36% | GIL | 3 | Hall of Famer Hodges who managed the Miracle Mets |
| 36% | BERRA | 5 | Manager who led both the Yankees and Mets to pennants |
| 36% | HODGES | 6 | Hall of Famer Gil who managed the 1969 "Miracle" Mets |
| 35% | NYC | 3 | Home of the Mets and the Yankees, briefly |
| 35% | NLE | 3 | MLB div. that includes the Mets and Braves |
| 34% | LARUSSA | 7 | Tony who managed two World Series championships for the Cardinals |
| 33% | MLB | 3 | Organization for the Yankees and Dodgers: Abbr. |
| 33% | MLB | 3 | Organization for the Dodgers and Mets: Abbr. |
| 32% | BASEBALL | 8 | Sport played by the Yankees, Braves and Red Sox |
| 32% | OYD | 3 | Poet who wrote "Fortune and love favor the brave" |
| 32% | ALICE | 5 | Girl who met the Mad Hatter and the March Hare |
| 31% | TORRE | 5 | MLB exec Joe who was the Yankees' manager for 12 seasons |
| 31% | TORRE | 5 | MLB executive Joe who was the Yankees' manager for 12 seasons |
| 31% | TORRE | 5 | MLB executive Joe who was the Yankees manager for 12 seasons |
| 31% | MLB | 3 | Organization for the Yankees and Mets: Abbr. |
| 31% | NOMO | 4 | Pitcher who played for the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Kintetsu Buffaloes |
| 31% | BERRA | 5 | Hall of Famer who was a Yankee manager and a Mets coach |
| 30% | WET | 3 | The ___ Bandits, villains in "Home Alone" who are played by Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern |
| 30% | CLETE | 5 | Boyer who played third base for the Yankees in the '50s and '60s |