| 100% | SOTO | 4 | Juan ___, three-time baseball All-Star from 2021-23 |
| 54% | EVAN | 4 | Three-time baseball All-Star Longoria |
| 47% | AARON | 5 | Baseball All-Star every year from 1955 to 1975 |
| 46% | SOTO | 4 | Three-time All-Star slugger Juan who was traded to the Yankees in 2023 |
| 46% | KEVINJOHNSON | 12 | Three-time NBA All-Star who served as mayor of Sacramento from 2008 to 2016 (2 wds.) |
| 44% | ALLIEQUIGLEY | 12 | Three-time WNBA All-Star who was the second-leading scorer for the Chicago Sky in 2021 season (2 wds.) |
| 44% | CAREW | 5 | All-Star 18 consecutive times from 1967 to 1984 |
| 43% | OTT | 3 | 12-time baseball All-Star |
| 43% | MANNY | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star ___ Trillo |
| 43% | ALOMAR | 6 | Six-time baseball All-Star Sandy |
| 43% | REYES | 5 | Four-time baseball All-Star Jose |
| 43% | STAUB | 5 | Six-time baseball All-Star Rusty |
| 43% | SOSA | 4 | Seven-time baseball All-Star Sammy |
| 43% | MAURY | 5 | Five-time baseball All-Star ___ Wills |
| 43% | SOSA | 4 | Seven-time baseball All-Star Sammy ___ |
| 43% | UTLEY | 5 | Six-time baseball All-Star Chase |
| 43% | MANNY | 5 | Five-time baseball All-Star Machado |
| 42% | BRETT | 5 | 12-time baseball All-Star, 1976-88 |
| 42% | OTT | 3 | 12-time baseball All-Star, 1934-45 |
| 42% | CURACAO | 7 | Country where Major League Baseball All-Stars Andruw Jones and Jurickson Profar hail from |
| 41% | ILYA | 4 | Three-time NHL All-Star Kovalchuk |
| 41% | BEN | 3 | Three-time NBA All-Star Simmons |
| 41% | MARC | 4 | Three-time NBA All-Star Gasol |
| 41% | EVAN | 4 | Three-time MLB All-Star Longoria |
| 41% | CURT | 4 | With 15-Across, three-time MLB All-Star whose Supreme Court battle paved the way for baseball free agency |
| 40% | MINOSO | 6 | Nine-time baseball All-Star nicknamed "The Cuban Comet" |
| 40% | GIAMBI | 6 | Jason who's a five-time baseball All-Star |
| 40% | ONEAL | 5 | Three-time NBA All-Star Game MVP |
| 39% | MILT | 4 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Pappas |
| 39% | NEN | 3 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Robb |