| 100% | BOSTONCREAM | 11 | Kind of pie that's actually a cake |
| 60% | BOSTON | 6 | ___ cream pie, misleading name of a dessert that's actually a cake, not a pie |
| 59% | HAY | 3 | Kind of "fever" that's not actually a fever, and is typically caused by pollen |
| 53% | GUINEA | 6 | Kind of pig that's not a pig |
| 52% | PIE | 3 | Boston cream ___ (dessert that's actually a cake) |
| 51% | EWE | 3 | Kind of sheep that's a homophone of "yew" |
| 51% | NOHIT | 5 | Kind of game that's a pitcher's dream |
| 51% | BUNDT | 5 | Kind of cake that's ring-shaped |
| 51% | TENMILE | 7 | Kind of race that's not quite a half-marathon |
| 50% | OWL | 3 | Kind of bird that's allowed as a pet at Hogwarts |
| 50% | MACADAMIA | 9 | A kind of nut that's associated with Hawaii |
| 50% | OREO | 4 | Kind of pie or cake |
| 50% | FOURH | 5 | Kind of club that's a hint to this puzzle's theme |
| 49% | GIN | 3 | Kind of rummy, or a liquor that's not rum |
| 49% | EASYA | 5 | Class that's a piece of cake |
| 49% | WALKINTHEPARK | 13 | Task that's a piece of cake |
| 48% | EXT | 3 | Kind of shot that's the opposite of a 47-Across in a screenplay |
| 48% | INT | 3 | Kind of shot that's the opposite of a 38-Down in a screenplay |
| 48% | OGEE | 4 | Kind of arch that resembles the shape of a Hershey's Kiss |
| 48% | NESSELRODE | 10 | Kind of pie named for a Russian count |
| 48% | REDSPOT | 7 | "Great" feature of Jupiter that's actually a centuries-long storm |
| 47% | RHUBARB | 7 | Tart pie filling that's actually a vegetable |
| 47% | MARBLE | 6 | Kind of cake with a swirl |
| 46% | RYE | 3 | Bread that's also a kind of booze |
| 46% | METABOLIC | 9 | Kind of reaction that triggers a breakdown? |
| 46% | DIATOM | 6 | Aquatic microorganism that's not actually composed of a pair of particles? |
| 45% | LIME | 4 | Key ___, type of pie that has a fresh citrusy flavor |
| 45% | MUD | 3 | Mississippi ___, type of pie that has a rich chocolate flavor |
| 45% | FOLK | 4 | Kind of music that may feature a mandolin |
| 45% | SEA | 3 | Kind of cucumber that isn't a vegetable |