| 100% | HOTTER | 6 | Kiss's second studio album, __ Than Hell |
| 53% | BREAKAWAY | 9 | Kelly Clarkson's second studio album |
| 53% | FEARLESS | 8 | Taylor Swift's second studio album |
| 51% | SLIM | 4 | "The ___ Shady LP" (Eminem's second studio album) |
| 51% | WATERMARK | 9 | Enya's second studio album, released in 1988 |
| 50% | BDAY | 4 | 23-/38-Across's second studio album, released in 2006 |
| 50% | HEAT | 4 | "Body ___," song from Selena Gomez's second studio album "Revival" |
| 50% | NEVERMIND | 9 | Nirvana's second studio album with In Bloom on it |
| 45% | SHOUT | 5 | "___ at the Devil," titular song from Motley Crue's second studio album which gained them widespread recognition |
| 43% | ONCEAGAIN | 9 | Second studio album by John Legend released in 2006: 2 wds. |
| 41% | NIGHTS | 6 | 2016 song by Frank Ocean from his second studio album "Blonde" |
| 41% | COMEASYOUARE | 12 | Kurt Cobain's hit song from Nirvana's second studio album "Nevermind": 4 wds. |
| 40% | UNRULYMESSIVE | 13 | "This ___ Made," the second studio album by Macklemore & Ryan Lewis: 3 wds |
| 40% | FERRARI | 7 | "White ___," 2016 song by Frank Ocean from his second studio album "Blonde" |
| 40% | FREE | 4 | "Futura ___," 2016 song by Frank Ocean from his second studio album "Blonde" |
| 40% | ROOSTER | 7 | 1993 song by Alice in Chains from their second studio album "Dirt" |
| 40% | WORST | 5 | "Favourite ___ Nightmare," 2007 second studio album by the rock band Arctic Monkeys |
| 40% | AZALEA | 6 | Rapper Iggy ___, who released her second studio album "In My Defense," last year |
| 39% | REMEMBER | 8 | "___ December," 2010 Demi Lovato song from her second studio album "Here We Go Again" |
| 37% | IFIAINTGOTYOU | 13 | Song from Alicia Keys' second studio album which received two Grammy nominations in 2005: 5 wds. |
| 37% | LEDZEPPELIN | 11 | Rock band whose second studio album includes the Robert Plant/Jimmy Page song "Thank You" (2 wds.) |
| 37% | STUPID | 6 | The second S in KISS, "keep it simple, __" |
| 35% | LOUD | 4 | "Thinking Out ___," song by Ed Sheeran from his second studio album "x" which he co-wrote with Amy Wadge |
| 35% | INUTERO | 7 | Nirvana's last studio album |
| 35% | CODA | 4 | Zep's final studio album |
| 35% | INUTERO | 7 | Nirvana's final studio album |
| 35% | PHOTOGRAPH | 10 | Song by Ed Sheeran from his second studio album "x" which he co-wrote with "Snow Patrol" member, Johnny McDaid |
| 34% | RAPTURE | 7 | Anita Baker's second album |
| 34% | BEN | 3 | Michael Jackson's second album |
| 33% | PUREHEROINE | 11 | Lorde's debut studio album: 2 wds. |