| 100% | CUBA | 4 | Largest island in the West Indies |
| 80% | STMARTIN | 8 | Island in the West Indies |
| 80% | ANTIGUA | 7 | Island in the West Indies |
| 74% | STKITTS | 7 | Nevis's sister island in the West Indies (2 wds.) |
| 68% | BARBADOS | 8 | Island state in the West Indies whose capital is Bridgetown |
| 63% | NAXOS | 5 | Largest island in the Cyclades |
| 63% | CUBA | 4 | Largest island in the Caribbean |
| 63% | GUAM | 4 | Largest island in the Marianas |
| 63% | SICILY | 6 | Largest island in the Mediterranean |
| 63% | LUZON | 5 | Largest island in the Philippines |
| 63% | ELBA | 4 | Largest island in the Tuscan Archipelago |
| 63% | SPITSBERGEN | 11 | Largest island in the Svalbard archipelago |
| 63% | SICILY | 6 | Largest island in the Mediterranean Sea |
| 63% | CRETE | 5 | Large island in the Mediterranean Sea |
| 63% | BORNEO | 6 | Large island in the Malay Archipelago |
| 62% | GREENLAND | 9 | Large island in the Arctic, colorful name |
| 61% | BORNEO | 6 | 3rd largest island in the world |
| 61% | SARDINIA | 8 | Second largest island in the Mediterranean |
| 61% | NEWGUINEA | 9 | 2nd largest island in the world |
| 60% | NAXOS | 5 | Largest island in the Cyclades group in the Aegean |
| 60% | TIMOR | 5 | Island in the East Indies |
| 60% | NEWBRITAIN | 10 | Largest island in the Bismarck Archipelago of Papua New Guinea |
| 59% | CARIBBEAN | 9 | Eastern __ Dollar is a currency in the West Indies |
| 59% | CRICKET | 7 | Bat-and-ball sport played in the West Indies |
| 58% | MANOFWAR | 8 | 2003 novel by Alexander Kent set in the West Indies |
| 57% | MAUI | 4 | 17th largest island in the US which was originally named "Ihikapalaumaewa" |
| 57% | CUBA | 4 | Large island of West Indies |
| 54% | NEWGUINEA | 9 | Island in the western South Pacific housing Indonesian provinces West Papua and Papua |
| 54% | DOMINICA | 8 | Country of the West Indies in the Caribbean Sea; capital Roseau |
| 54% | FRASER | 6 | Largest sand island in the world: __ Island |