| 100% | UGLIER | 6 | Less pretty |
| 86% | UGLIER | 6 | Even less pretty |
| 75% | BONITOS | 7 | Fish with a Spanish name meaning little pretties |
| 71% | LUCYHALE | 8 | Pretty Little Liar named Aria Montgomery |
| 69% | AMAPOLA | 7 | Pretty Little Poppy in a 1924 song |
| 68% | LUCYHALE | 8 | Aria on Pretty Little Liars |
| 68% | SHAY | 4 | Mitchell of Pretty Little Liars |
| 67% | BENSON | 6 | Ashley, star of Pretty Little Liars |
| 67% | HEAD | 4 | "Don't worry your pretty little ___" |
| 66% | CUTEY | 5 | A less-common spelling for a pretty, adorable one |
| 65% | MARE | 4 | Pretty much any "My Little Pony" character, for example |
| 65% | SARA | 4 | __ Shepard, writer of Pretty Little Liars novels |
| 63% | MELISSA | 7 | Teen Wolf McCall or Pretty Little Liars Hastings |
| 61% | ARIA | 4 | Character in the hit TV show Pretty Little Liars |
| 61% | ILL | 3 | "___ get you, my pretty, and your little dog, too!" |
| 57% | ADORE | 5 | "My cherie amour, pretty little one that I ___" (Stevie Wonder lyric) |
| 57% | ADORE | 5 | "My cherie amour, pretty little one that I ___" (Stevie Wonder lyrics) |
| 55% | MTV | 3 | "Pretty Little Mamas" network |
| 55% | ARIA | 4 | "Pretty Little Liars" character |
| 54% | TOTO | 4 | The little dog of “I’ll get you, my pretty, and your little dog, too!” |
| 53% | NIA | 3 | "Pretty Little Liars" actress Peeples |
| 53% | IAN | 3 | "Pretty Little Liars" actor Harding |
| 53% | LOWE | 4 | "Pretty Little Liars" actor Chad |
| 53% | NIA | 3 | "Pretty Little liars" actress, Peeples |
| 53% | SARA | 4 | "Pretty Little Liars" author Shepard |
| 53% | ARIA | 4 | "Pretty Little Liars" character Montgomery |
| 53% | SARA | 4 | "Pretty Little Liars" novelist Shepard |
| 53% | MTV | 3 | "Pretty Little Mamas" network: Abbr. |
| 53% | CALEB | 5 | "Pretty Little Liars" main character |
| 53% | SHAY | 4 | "Pretty Little Liars" actress Mitchell |