| 100% | ABNER | 5 | Li'l Broadway role for Peter Palmer |
| 46% | MRMOTO | 6 | Role for Peter Lorre |
| 45% | YENTE | 5 | Broadway role for Bea Arthur |
| 43% | LOMAN | 5 | Iconic Broadway role for Cobb |
| 43% | ULEE | 4 | Title role for Peter Fonda |
| 43% | ULEE | 4 | 1997 title role for Peter Fonda |
| 43% | ULEE | 4 | Giant role for Peter Fonda, 1997 |
| 43% | NERO | 4 | 1951 historical role for Peter Ustinov |
| 43% | MRMOTO | 6 | Eight-time role for Peter Lorre |
| 43% | CASEY | 5 | "Sports Night" role for Peter Krause |
| 43% | CYRANO | 6 | 2021 title role for Peter Dinklage |
| 42% | ULEE | 4 | Title role for Peter Fonda in 1997 |
| 42% | LORDJIM | 7 | 1965 title role for Peter O'Toole |
| 42% | ULEE | 4 | Oscar-nominated title role for Peter Fonda |
| 40% | NERO | 4 | Historical role for Peter Lorre in "The Story of Mankind" |
| 40% | ELSA | 4 | Role for Ciara Renee in Broadway's "Frozen" |
| 40% | SHAFT | 5 | Role for Richard Roundtree and Samuel L. Jackson |
| 39% | CASTCATSACTS | 12 | Fill roles for a Broadway show? |
| 36% | GIGI | 4 | Broadway title role for Audrey Hepburn |
| 35% | RFK | 3 | Peter Sarsgaard's role in 2016's "Jackie," for short |
| 35% | USTINOV | 7 | Peter —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Topkapi |
| 35% | USTINOV | 7 | Peter —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar-winner for Topkapi |
| 34% | BOOP | 4 | Betty ___ (Broadway role for Jasmine Amy Rogers) |
| 34% | SHANE | 5 | "The L Word" role for Katherine Moennig |
| 34% | BETTE | 5 | "The L Word" role for Jennifer Beals |
| 34% | RENO | 4 | Role for Ferrell on "S.N.L." |
| 34% | FALK | 4 | Peter —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for Murder, Inc |
| 34% | SELLERS | 7 | Peter —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Being There |
| 33% | OTOOLE | 6 | Peter —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar-nominee for The Ruling Class |
| 33% | OBAMA | 5 | Role for Jay Pharoah on 2010s "S.N.L." |