| 100% | ANONYMOUS | 9 | Like a blog commenter whose identity is secret |
| 42% | ODD | 3 | Like a sock whose mate is missing |
| 42% | AQUEOUS | 7 | Like a solution whose solvent is water |
| 42% | SHOD | 4 | Like a horse whose hooves are protected |
| 42% | HOR | 3 | Like a line whose slope is zero: Abbr. |
| 42% | DYED | 4 | Like a beard whose gray is now hidden |
| 40% | ANON | 4 | "Author's identity is a secret," for short |
| 40% | ANON | 4 | Like a quote whose original speaker can't be identified: Abbr. |
| 40% | SCRIPTED | 8 | Like a TV show whose lines are all written in advance |
| 37% | SLY | 3 | Like a wink that suggests "This is our little secret" |
| 36% | BATMAN | 6 | Hero whose secret identity is Bruce Wayne |
| 35% | SAUCE | 5 | "The Secret ___," 2021 Tori Anderson film whose name could be a cooking ingredient |
| 35% | JOHNDOE | 7 | Name given to a male whose identity is unknown |
| 35% | JANEDOE | 7 | Name given to a female whose identity is unknown |
| 35% | EYE | 3 | Body part whose name is pronounced like a vowel |
| 35% | NHL | 3 | Sports league whose logo is shaped like a shield |
| 35% | ISIS | 4 | Egyptian goddess whose headdress was shaped like a throne |
| 35% | CIS | 3 | Like one whose gender identity corresponds with the sex they were assigned at birth, for short |
| 34% | OUT | 3 | Like a secret that's no longer secret |
| 34% | DOE | 3 | John ___ (man whose identity is unknown) |
| 34% | SPY | 3 | Agent whose identity is usually classified |
| 34% | SPY | 3 | One whose identity is often classified |
| 34% | IMO | 3 | Start of many a blog comment |
| 34% | ANON | 4 | Internet group whose identities are unknown |
| 34% | CODED | 5 | Like a secret message |
| 34% | UNNAMED | 7 | Like a secret admirer |
| 34% | SUPREME | 7 | Like a deified being |
| 34% | WASP | 4 | Marvel character whose secret identity is Hope van Dyne |
| 34% | ANON | 4 | Someone whose identity is unknown, for short |
| 34% | ANON | 4 | One whose identity is unknown, for short |