| 100% | RAT | 3 | Like a large mouse, rodent that's known as a pest |
| 46% | COCKROACH | 9 | Scavenging beetle-like bug known as a pest |
| 44% | RAT | 3 | Like a large mouse |
| 42% | GERBIL | 6 | Mouse-like, burrowing rodent, kept as a pet |
| 42% | SLUG | 4 | Pest that's like a shell-less snail |
| 42% | TRIO | 4 | Group that's not as large as a quartet |
| 42% | VOLE | 4 | Rodent like a stocky mouse |
| 41% | PANDA | 5 | Large Chinese animal that's the same colors as a crossword puzzle |
| 41% | NAT | 3 | Man's nickname that sounds like a pest |
| 41% | MANTARAY | 8 | Large flat fish, sometimes known as a devilfish |
| 40% | STRUCTURE | 9 | Any large item that's made, like a building or a bridge |
| 40% | ORCA | 4 | Large mammal also known as a killer whale |
| 40% | SAMOA | 5 | Girl Scout cookie containing coconut that's also known as a Caramel deLite |
| 40% | PDA | 3 | Old-fashioned gadget that was known as a handheld computer: Abbr. |
| 40% | MANATEE | 7 | Large marine mammal also known as a "sea cow" |
| 39% | LLAMA | 5 | Animal that looks like a large alpaca |
| 39% | RAT | 3 | Rodent that resembles a mouse |
| 39% | VOLE | 4 | Hamster relative also known as a meadow mouse |
| 39% | NAKEDMOLERAT | 12 | Burrowing rodent also known as a sand puppy |
| 39% | GUINEAPIG | 9 | Pet rodent that is larger than a hamster |
| 39% | SCRUB | 5 | "A guy that thinks he's fly and is also known as a buster," per a #1 TLC hit |
| 38% | CLEAVER | 7 | Large rectangular knife that looks like a hatchet |
| 37% | OGEE | 4 | S-shaped molding that sounds like a sighed phrase |
| 37% | COFFEEBEAN | 10 | Globally used seed that usually comes in twos, but when there is only one inside the "cherry", it's known as a peaberry |
| 36% | PODGORICA | 9 | Balkan city, now a capital, that was known as Titograd from 1946-1992 |
| 36% | SQUARE | 6 | Set ___, instrument used in Geometry class that is also known as a Triangle |
| 36% | ANIME | 5 | Genre that uses a caricature style known as chibi |
| 36% | GONG | 4 | Large percussion instrument that's hit with a hammer |
| 36% | COATI | 5 | Southern US animal with a long, pig-like snout that some locals know as the hog-nosed coon |
| 36% | LOOSE | 5 | Like clothes that are a size larger |