| 100% | PITTED | 6 | Like the moon's landscape and many olives |
| 49% | URANIAN | 7 | Like the moons Titania and Oberon |
| 46% | SALTY | 5 | Like the ocean and most potato chips |
| 46% | CRATERED | 8 | Like the moon's surface |
| 46% | CRATERED | 8 | Like the moon’s surface |
| 45% | MUDDY | 5 | Like the habitats of many lugworms and fiddler crabs |
| 45% | PLUMPEST | 8 | Like the most juicy and well-rounded Thanksgiving turkey |
| 45% | SWEET | 5 | Like the taste of most desserts and dessert wines |
| 43% | BESTINPRAYERS | 13 | Like the most devout churchgoers … and another anagram of 20-Across |
| 43% | MOATED | 6 | Like the temple complex of Angkor Wat and many old English castles |
| 42% | FOURSPEED | 9 | Like most manual transmissions in the 1970s and '80s |
| 41% | CRATERS | 7 | Much of the moon's landscape |
| 41% | SILENT | 6 | Like the "s" in "aisle" and "island" |
| 40% | DOMED | 5 | Like the U.S. Capitol and the Taj Mahal |
| 40% | PEAGREEN | 8 | Like the Owl and the Pussycat's boat |
| 40% | ALLFEMALE | 9 | Like the Supremes and the Go-Go's |
| 40% | MADEFORTV | 9 | Like the movies "Brian's Song" and "Sharknado" |
| 40% | ROMAN | 5 | Like the Circus Maximus and Trajan's Market |
| 40% | TIDAL | 5 | Like the ocean's ebb and flow |
| 40% | TURNERESQUE | 11 | Like landscape paintings that focus more on color and lighting than fine detail |
| 40% | AURAL | 5 | Like many exams done at the "Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary" in Boston |
| 39% | PEAGREEN | 8 | Like the Owl and the Pussy-Cat's boat |
| 39% | HALOED | 6 | Like the moon, at times |
| 39% | ONEACT | 6 | Like the plays “Krapp’s Last Tape” and “No Exit” |
| 39% | LUNISOLAR | 9 | Concerning both the moon and sun's motions |
| 39% | ATWAR | 5 | Like the U.S. and Spain in 1898 |
| 39% | GOOEY | 5 | Melty, like the inside of a s'more |
| 38% | INCAN | 5 | Like the moon goddess Mama Quilla |
| 38% | MARTIAN | 7 | Like the landscape currently being explored by NASA's Perseverance rover |
| 38% | PUNNY | 5 | Like the horror movie titles "Chopping Mall" and "Santa's Slay" |