| 100% | CAMPY | 5 | Like the movie "But I'm a Cheerleader" |
| 54% | CLEADUVALL | 10 | "But I'm a Cheerleader" actress |
| 54% | CLEADUVALL | 10 | "But I'm a Cheerleader" star |
| 52% | PUNK | 4 | I'm a music genre with bands like Green Day and The Ramones |
| 51% | AMADEUS | 7 | Movie with the line "I'm a vulgar man. But I assure you, my music is not" |
| 51% | CLEA | 4 | DuVall of "But I'm A Cheerleader" |
| 50% | ATHROB | 6 | Like the heart during a horror movie |
| 50% | REMADE | 6 | Like the movie A Star Is Born, in 1954, 1976, and 2018 |
| 50% | UNCUT | 5 | Like the DVD version of a movie, maybe |
| 48% | SCALY | 5 | Like the skin of a trout but not a shark |
| 48% | ETS | 3 | Aliens, like the one in a Spielberg movie: Abbr. |
| 47% | ETS | 3 | Aliens, like the one in a 1982 Spielberg movie: Abbr. |
| 46% | TRITE | 5 | Like a sunset at the end of a movie |
| 46% | LYONNE | 6 | Natasha of “But I’m a Cheerleader” |
| 45% | TIDALWAVE | 9 | Like a tsunami but caused by the moon's gravity |
| 45% | SPOILERY | 8 | Like a movie review that gives away all the twists |
| 45% | JLO | 3 | She said, "I'm like a little roach. You think I'm gone for good ... But then you go to get a glass of water in the middle of the night, and boom! I got an album." |
| 45% | BUCATINI | 8 | Like spaghetti, but with a hole down the center |
| 45% | UNCUT | 5 | Like the director's version of a movie |
| 45% | EPIC | 4 | Vast, like a "Lord of the Rings" movie |
| 45% | APT | 3 | Like the anagramming of A DECIMAL POINT to make I'M A DOT IN PLACE |
| 44% | CLONED | 6 | Like the I.B.M. PC, often |
| 44% | ONE | 3 | "You may say I'm a dreamer, but I'm not the only ___," quote by the Beatles musician John Lennon |
| 44% | ONEEYED | 7 | Like a cyclops or some of the Minions in "Despicable Me": Hyph. |
| 44% | MINSTREL | 8 | I'm a medieval entertainer, like a singer |
| 43% | NATASHA | 7 | Lyonne who starred in “But I’m a Cheerleader” |
| 43% | MATERIALWITNESS | 15 | ... but I saw everything, so I'm the __! |
| 43% | CABANA | 6 | Like a gazebo on the beach, but with fabric walls |
| 42% | TEAPOT | 6 | I'm a little __, short and stout, said the rhyme |
| 42% | GORY | 4 | Like the movie mentioned in 30a |