| 100% | CYBORGS | 7 | Living creatures that are enhanced with robotics |
| 50% | ZEBRAS | 6 | Creatures that are actually black with white stripes |
| 47% | PET | 3 | Furry creature that lives with you |
| 40% | HAG | 3 | ___fish: jawless, marine animals that are the only known living animals with a skull, but no spinal column |
| 39% | CENTAUR | 7 | Creature that is part human, part horse |
| 39% | BIRDS | 5 | Modern creatures that are technically dinosaurs |
| 39% | ORC | 3 | Fictional humanoid creature that is ugly |
| 38% | TURTLES | 7 | Fictional ninja mutant creatures that are teenaged |
| 37% | FULLSET | 7 | Each nail is enhanced with gel or acrylic |
| 37% | PLEA | 4 | It might be enhanced with puppy dog eyes |
| 37% | CENTAUR | 7 | A creature that is half man half horse |
| 37% | ELK | 3 | Antlered creature that is Utah's state animal |
| 37% | MOOSE | 5 | Antlered creature that is Alaska's state animal |
| 37% | SEALIFE | 7 | Creatures that live in marine waters |
| 37% | SEATURTLES | 10 | Creatures that divers sometimes swim with |
| 37% | PORPOISE | 8 | Creature that echolocates with a melon |
| 37% | NEWT | 4 | Creature that can be "red-spotted" |
| 37% | RAYS | 4 | Sea creatures that are a homophone of 47-Across |
| 37% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Modern legendary creature that is a blood-sucking monster |
| 37% | LLAMAS | 6 | Creatures that may be mistaken for alpacas |
| 37% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Creature that sucks blood and lives eternally |
| 36% | TICKETTORIDE | 12 | The Beatles #1 song with the lyric "She said that living with me / Is bringing her down" (3 wds.) |
| 36% | TICKETTORIDE | 12 | No. 1 Beatles song with the lyric "She said that living with me / Is bringing her down" (3 wds.) |
| 36% | MINOTAUR | 8 | A Greek creature that is half-man and half-bull |
| 36% | LOCHNESS | 8 | Modern legendary creature that is a sea monster: 2 wds. |
| 36% | FROG | 4 | Creature that may be transformed after a kiss |
| 36% | GREMLIN | 7 | Fantastic creature that multiplies with water |
| 36% | EEL | 3 | Wriggly creature that rhymes with "squeal" |
| 36% | OGRE | 4 | Type of creature that Shrek is |
| 36% | OGRE | 4 | Kind of creature that Shrek is |