| 100% | IGUANA | 6 | Lizard often mistaken for a chameleon |
| 61% | HARE | 4 | Animal often mistaken for a rabbit |
| 61% | RAVEN | 5 | Bird often mistaken for a crow |
| 60% | TOMATO | 6 | Red fruit often mistaken for a vegetable |
| 60% | PORPOISE | 8 | Blunt-snouted whale often mistaken for a dolphin |
| 53% | HOVERFLY | 8 | Insect often mistaken for a wasp or bee that feeds on the nectar and pollen of flowers |
| 45% | ESP | 3 | Coincidence is often mistaken for it |
| 45% | TOMATO | 6 | Red fruit often mistaken for vegetable |
| 45% | NUTMEG | 6 | Brown spice often mistaken for cinnamon |
| 45% | GOLD | 4 | Pyrite is often mistaken for it |
| 45% | NEWBIE | 6 | Not a veteran, often blamed for mistakes |
| 44% | YAM | 3 | Tuber that a sweet potato is often mistaken for |
| 44% | CORNSNAKE | 9 | Species often mistaken for the venomous copperhead |
| 44% | EEL | 3 | It may be mistaken for a snake |
| 44% | GATOR | 5 | One might be mistaken for a croc |
| 44% | TOMATO | 6 | Red fruit, usually mistaken for a vegetable |
| 44% | ASPEN | 5 | Tree sometimes mistaken for a white birch |
| 44% | EEL | 3 | Fish sometimes mistaken for a sea snake |
| 44% | RAT | 3 | One might be mistaken for a mouse |
| 43% | CABBAGE | 7 | Green or purple veggie often mistaken for lettuce |
| 43% | CUCUMBER | 8 | Long green salad fruit, mistaken for a veg |
| 43% | EEL | 3 | Fish that might be mistaken for a snake |
| 43% | CATSEAR | 7 | Plant that may be mistaken for a dandelion |
| 43% | CAW | 3 | Cry that may be mistaken for a croak |
| 43% | FAULT | 5 | Responsibility for a mistake |
| 43% | AMENDS | 6 | Atonement for a mistake |
| 43% | OWNSIT | 6 | Answers for a mistake |
| 43% | CALLONTHECARPET | 15 | Criticize for a mistake |
| 43% | EEL | 3 | Fish that might be mistaken for a sea snake |
| 43% | MANATEE | 7 | Aquatic behemoth that may be mistaken for a dugong |