| 100% | BOAT | 4 | Lonely Island "I'm on a ___" |
| 65% | FIJI | 4 | I'm an island country in the South Pacific Ocean with a white dove and lion on my flag |
| 65% | TPAIN | 5 | R&B singer featured on the Lonely Island's "I'm on a Boat": Hyph. |
| 64% | TREE | 4 | Lonely growth on a cartoon desert island |
| 62% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (Lonely Island song) |
| 59% | ROLL | 4 | "I'm on a __!" |
| 58% | ROLL | 4 | "I'm on a ___" (lucky streak) |
| 58% | ROLL | 4 | "I'm on a ___!" (winning streak) |
| 58% | ROLL | 4 | "I'm on a ___!" (winning spree) |
| 57% | ROLL | 4 | "I'm on a ___!" (streak of luck) |
| 56% | DIET | 4 | "I'm on a strictly vegan ___." (eating regime) |
| 55% | ABOAT | 5 | "I'm on ___" (hit parody song for the Lonely Island) |
| 55% | MALE | 4 | M, on a form |
| 55% | GAY | 3 | Ellen's quote on a 1997 Time magazine cover, "Yep, I'm ___" |
| 55% | COMMA | 5 | It's next to M on a keyboard |
| 55% | COMMA | 5 | Punctuation mark next to M on a keyboard |
| 54% | SOS | 3 | "I'm stranded on an island and all I have are rocks!" |
| 54% | ONE | 3 | I, on a sundial |
| 54% | UGANDA | 6 | I'm an African country with a grey crowned crane on my flag |
| 54% | MAROONED | 8 | Abandoned on a desolate island |
| 54% | WAVE | 4 | Crasher on a desert island |
| 54% | MAROON | 6 | Strand on a desert island |
| 54% | MAROONING | 9 | Stranding on a deserted island |
| 54% | MAROONED | 8 | Stranded on a desert island |
| 53% | IOTA | 4 | I, on a frat house |
| 53% | BHUTAN | 6 | I'm an Asian country near the Himalayas with a dragon on my flag |
| 53% | ONA | 3 | "I'm ___ Boat" (2009 Lonely Island hit) |
| 53% | STRANDED | 8 | Stuck on a desert island, say |
| 53% | CASTAWAYS | 9 | People stranded on a desert island |
| 53% | CASTAWAYS | 9 | Those marooned on a desert island |