| 100% | ANDYPETTITTE | 12 | Longtime Yankees pitcher who sang in his high school choir: 2 wds. |
| 73% | WALTERPAYTON | 12 | Longtime Chicago Bears running back who sang in his high school choir: 2 wds. |
| 59% | DANICAPATRICK | 13 | Race car driver who sang in her high school choir: 2 wds. |
| 43% | DAVIDCONE | 9 | Yankees pitcher who threw a perfect game in 1999: 2 wds. |
| 43% | DOMINGOGERMAN | 13 | Yankees pitcher who threw a perfect game in 2023: 2 wds. |
| 42% | DONLARSEN | 9 | Yankees pitcher who threw a perfect game in the 1956 World Series: 2 wds. |
| 42% | ALLIEREYNOLDS | 13 | Yankees pitcher who threw two no-hitters in a single season in 1951: 2 wds. |
| 41% | DONLARSEN | 9 | Yankees pitcher who pitched a perfect game in the World Series on 10/8/56: 2 wds. |
| 41% | GERRITCOLE | 10 | Pitcher who signed a $324 million contract with the Yankees in 2019: 2 wds. |
| 40% | JOETORRE | 8 | Yankees manager who was ejected 66 times in his career: 2 wds. |
| 39% | ZACKBRITTON | 11 | New York Yankees pitcher who gave up the walk-off home run in the 30-Across game ( 2 wds.) |
| 39% | SANDYKOUFAX | 11 | Hall of Fame Dodgers pitcher who recorded three "immaculate" innings in his career: 2 wds. |
| 39% | JIMABBOTT | 9 | One-handed Yankees pitcher who threw a no-hitter in 1993 and never played in the minor leagues: 2 wds. |
| 39% | TOMMYJOHN | 9 | Pitcher who's known for his successful elbow surgery and played to age 46, in 1989: 2 wds. |
| 39% | RANDYJOHNSON | 12 | Hall of Fame Astros/Diamondbacks pitcher who recorded two "immaculate" innings in his career: 2 wds. |
| 38% | SANDYKOUFAX | 11 | Left-handed pitcher who won his fourth and final World Series with the Dodgers in 1965: 2 wds. |
| 37% | MARIANORIVERA | 13 | Yankees relief pitcher who won the MLB Comeback Player of the Year Award in 2013: 2 wds. |
| 37% | GLEECLUB | 8 | High school singing group: 2 wds. |
| 36% | ALEXRODRIGUEZ | 13 | Former Yankees slugger who, in his 2012 children's book, is a young baseballer learning the value of practice: 2 wds. |
| 34% | PHILNIEKRO | 10 | Braves knuckleball pitcher who played to age 48, in 1987: 2 wds. |
| 34% | MARKDAVIS | 9 | Padres relief pitcher who won the Cy Young in 1989: 2 wds. |
| 34% | ROLLIEFINGERS | 13 | Brewers relief pitcher who won the Cy Young in 1981: 2 wds. |
| 34% | ERICGAGNE | 9 | Dodgers relief pitcher who won the Cy Young in 2003: 2 wds. |
| 34% | JAKEPEAVY | 9 | Padres pitcher who won the NL Triple Crown in 2007: 2 wds. |
| 34% | CLAYTONKERSHAW | 14 | Dodgers pitcher who won the NL Triple Crown in 2011: 2 wds. |
| 33% | ZACEFRON | 8 | "High School Musical" actor who voices Fred in "Scoob!" (2 wds.) |
| 33% | WOODROWWILSON | 13 | Musically inclined 20th-century US president who was in his law school's glee club: 2 wds. |
| 33% | ALYANKOVIC | 10 | "Weird" satirical songwriter and performer who was valedictorian of his high school class: 2 wds. |
| 33% | MARIANORIVERA | 13 | Longtime Yankees closer who's retiring at the end of the 2013 season: 2 wds. |
| 33% | DWIGHTHOWARD | 12 | The Orlando Magic drafted him out of high school in 2004: 2 wds. |