| 100% | SCAMPI | 6 | Made with garlic and butter |
| 73% | SCAMPI | 6 | Dish made with garlic butter |
| 71% | AIOLI | 5 | Sauce made with garlic and olive oil |
| 68% | SCAMPI | 6 | Shrimp ___ (seafood dish made with garlic butter) |
| 66% | RICHER | 6 | Made with more butter and cream, perhaps |
| 64% | ALFREDO | 7 | Creamy sauce made with Parmesan and butter |
| 63% | PESTO | 5 | Sauce made with basil, garlic, and pine nuts |
| 63% | CARAMEL | 7 | Sticky sweet substance made with butter and sugar |
| 63% | BEARNAISE | 9 | French sauce made with butter, eggs and herbs |
| 63% | PENUCHE | 7 | Fudge candy made with brown sugar and butter |
| 63% | FLUFFERNUTTERS | 14 | Sandwiches made with peanut butter and marshmallow creme |
| 62% | HOLLANDAISE | 11 | Sauce made with butter, egg yolks and lemon juice |
| 62% | BECHAMEL | 8 | Basic white sauce made with milk, flour and butter |
| 62% | FLAPJACK | 8 | Baked bar made with oats, syrup, sugar and butter |
| 62% | CARAMEL | 7 | Shade of brown made with melted sugar and butter |
| 62% | ANTSONALOG | 10 | Snack made with celery sticks, peanut butter and raisins |
| 61% | POUNDCAKE | 9 | Dessert made with equal parts sugar, eggs, butter, and flour |
| 61% | BRIOCHE | 7 | Sweet French bread made with eggs and butter |
| 61% | ANTSONALOG | 10 | Snack made with celery, peanut butter and raisins |
| 61% | SCAMPI | 6 | Shrimp dish with butter and garlic |
| 60% | CARAMELS | 8 | Chewy candies that might be made with butter, cream, and sugar |
| 59% | MARINARA | 8 | Type of pizza made with tomato sauce, oregano, garlic and olive oil |
| 55% | FUDGE | 5 | Candy made primarily with sugar, butter, and milk |
| 55% | SANDWICH | 8 | Food made with bread, peanut butter, and jelly, that might be enjoyed at a picnic |
| 54% | AIOLI | 5 | Mediterranean sauce made with garlic |
| 54% | NAAN | 4 | Bread often made with garlic |
| 52% | AIOLI | 5 | Sauce made with garlic, similar to mayonnaise |
| 52% | SEWN | 4 | Made with needle and thread |
| 52% | FORGING | 7 | Making with fire and hammers |
| 52% | RUM | 3 | Hot buttered ___, mixed winter drink made with spices and butter |